
Started By
Message
Question for my christian brothers
Posted on 3/22/16 at 5:57 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 5:57 pm
With Easter coming up i have a question about the trinity. With the Holy Spirit is that an interpretation of christ rising from the grave? Also is wine in biblical time the equivalent of grape juice in our time now?
This post was edited on 3/22/16 at 6:01 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 6:19 pm to SCDawg
quote:
With the Holy Spirit is that an interpretation of christ rising from the grave?
Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are not names of different parts of God, but one name for God. They are co-equal and co-eternal.
quote:
Also is wine in biblical time the equivalent of grape juice in our time now?
Catholics believe that at Communion that the wine is his blood, the bread is his body. Not symbols or representations. Some denominations believe that they actually become the body and blood of Christ. Others believe in the spiritual presence of Christ in the Eucharist. Then you even have some hat see it only as a symbolic representation of the act.
It differs among denominations. So whether they use grape juice or wine might be determined by their views of the Eucharist.
This post was edited on 3/22/16 at 6:21 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 6:27 pm to SCDawg
No and no.
Wine was wine ... but the argument has always been made, by the tee-totalers, that it was watered-down or often vinegary.
Who knows for sure.
We do know that wine was used to disinfect water back in those days, to kill germs and bacteria, so the watering-down theory is probably likely ... and later "grog" was basically watered-down liquor used for the same reasons - because the alcohol content killed bacteria.
They didn't know why it worked, but if you drank water mixed with alcohol you were less likely to get sick back then ... so that's what a lot of people drank.
ETA: Best description of the Holy Trinity I've ever found: https://carm.org/what-trinity
Wine was wine ... but the argument has always been made, by the tee-totalers, that it was watered-down or often vinegary.
Who knows for sure.
We do know that wine was used to disinfect water back in those days, to kill germs and bacteria, so the watering-down theory is probably likely ... and later "grog" was basically watered-down liquor used for the same reasons - because the alcohol content killed bacteria.
They didn't know why it worked, but if you drank water mixed with alcohol you were less likely to get sick back then ... so that's what a lot of people drank.
ETA: Best description of the Holy Trinity I've ever found: https://carm.org/what-trinity
This post was edited on 3/22/16 at 6:30 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 6:54 pm to Old Sarge
quote:this although some of the hardcore buddies of mine said the wine was non alcoholic.
No and no
If it didn't have any alcohol in it, it couldn't be called wine.
Posted on 3/22/16 at 7:20 pm to SCDawg
quote:
Also is wine in biblical time the equivalent of grape juice in our time now?
Depends if you live in a dry county.
Posted on 3/22/16 at 7:24 pm to SCDawg
The OP is just one example of things I don't miss about Christianity.
Edited: Downvote all you want. It just feels good to no longer have to give bullshite answers to try to aline god with your denomination du jour.
Edited: Downvote all you want. It just feels good to no longer have to give bullshite answers to try to aline god with your denomination du jour.
This post was edited on 3/22/16 at 7:41 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 7:28 pm to SCDawg
Wine was wine. In HS when our youth group leader told us we should never drink ever, not even moderately. He gave the "it's basically grape juice" excuse to explain why it was okay for Jesus to drink wine saying that they made it differently back then. I raised my hand and said "yeah, but it ferments and gets stronger" and he was not happy with me 
Posted on 3/22/16 at 7:54 pm to BowlJackson
Im a christian i understand that the trinity is equal. I just thought for some reason the holy spirit could be explained as jesus risen from the grave
Posted on 3/22/16 at 7:55 pm to BowlJackson
And i dont understand the alcohol is bad debacle i dont have a problem with it.
Posted on 3/22/16 at 8:49 pm to scrooster
quote:
Wine was wine ... but the argument has always been made, by the tee-totalers, that it was watered-down or often vinegary.
Yep. Teetotalers ruin everything
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:11 pm to memphisplaya
quote:
Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are not names of different parts of God, but one name for God.
Yes, and No. They are different parts, but they are also 100% of each other.
What is a little strange is that the ancient jews believed in a multiple God, but that he was a multitude. Not only 3.
In fact, in the original Hebrew in Genesis when God says "We will create man in our image." A) He is speaking spiritually, not physically B) He is not talking to the Angels, nor is he talking to the trinity. So who is he talking to. Who was the "Our" to ancient Hebrews. There is no definitive answer on this.
Another interesting thought to piggyback on that is that God made it clear he is the Alpha and Omega, he created all things, and that we are to never have any God's before him. Despite this, the Bible NEVER ONCE says lesser gods do not exist.
quote:
Also is wine in biblical time the equivalent of grape juice in our time now?
No, it was fermented because the fermentation cleansed it of bacteria and made it safe to drink. However, it would have been far weaker in alcoholic content because the process would not have been allowed to continue long enough for the equivalent of a modern wine to develop.
This post was edited on 3/22/16 at 9:13 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:12 pm to SCDawg
The Trinity
Using grapes instead of wine
You can view it religiously or historically. Peace be with you.
Using grapes instead of wine
You can view it religiously or historically. Peace be with you.
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:14 pm to Old Sarge
quote:
I don't understand this
Basically read the whole post by VaBamaMan, everything he said is the kind of crap I no longer have to say, or think. And I'm so glad for that.
This post was edited on 3/22/16 at 9:16 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:23 pm to Stacked
quote:
Basically read the whole post by VaBamaMan, everything he said is the kind of crap I no longer have to say, or think. And I'm so glad for that.
I didn't twist anything. In fact, both of those go against the direct teachings of my "denomination". I was simply giving the most direct biblical answers I could. Plus I threw a little bit of fun in there for the hardliners.
That was literally the basic facts of how to answer the questions he has from a Biblical perspective. I would love to know where you think I was jumping through hoops to try to explain something.
For the record, I've become much less dogmatic the older I've gotten, and the more I've studied independently. Except for one thing, I probably despise the American "church" more than you do. Such a weird twisted version of Christianity, but its a monster that I'm not sure will ever be changed. It will only die.
Edit: The part regarding the ancient Hebrew's belief systems would make someone walk away with more questions than answers. So how would that be dogmatic?
This post was edited on 3/22/16 at 9:25 pm
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:25 pm to SCDawg
Isn't Easter a pagan holiday?!
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:27 pm to jangalang
quote:
Isn't Easter a pagan holiday?!
Originally, yes. Along with Christmas, and maybe others which didn't last through the centuries. They were pagan holidays subverted by the Roman's so as to still have an excuse for their celebrations on those days, but while also doing away with the former pagan underpinnings of those holidays.
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:31 pm to VaBamaMan
Your understanding of it is much greater than mine. Thanks for the insight. Seems like the Christian community should celebrate resurrection day and completely do away with the Easter aspect along with the random bunny and its eggs.
Posted on 3/22/16 at 9:37 pm to SCDawg
Alcohol itself isn't bad. Nowhere in the bible does it say not to drink alcohol. It says don't get drunk. Super traditional Christians view it that way, but I certainly don't think it's a sin to have a beer every now and then.

Popular
Back to top

13










