quote:
They aren't? Let me ask you this, are there any rules for substitution for the offense? For the defense? If so, what are they?

Your answer will tell me if you know anything.

the only thing i can think of is that the defense can briefly have more than 11 field to anticipate offensive formations, whereas the offense cant break huddle with more than 11 or have more than 11 in the huddle for more than 3 seconds, or possibly you are referring to this excerpt about timing once the o has substituted, providing time for the d to substitute as well

quote:
'While in the process of substitution or simulated substitution, Team A is prohibited from rushing quickly to the line of scrimmage with the obvious attempt of creating a defensive disadvantage. If the ball is ready for play, the game officials will not permit the ball to be snapped until Team B has placed substitutes in position and replaced players have left the field of play. Team B must react promptly with its substitutes'

quote:
Tell me basically what rules must the d adhere to pre snap and what must the o? Count them up and get back to me.

who ever said the d had to adhere to more rules presnap than the o? the reason there are so many presnap rules on the o is because they have the ball, they know the play, they know the snap count. the defense has to be able to be free to react. its always been that way, or at least under modern rules. the defense is reactive, so the rules are on the offense becasue they are the ones with control over that stuff. everybody flipped their shite when someone suggests an additional tiny presnap rule adjustment, which would be only one of many, and in response propose rules that would completely change the way defenses work and have worked for over 50 years and try to equate them. getting rid of the meerkat oline is not equivalent to eliminating blitzing or making defenses adhere to motion rules. one is a tiny adjustment to existing rules, one is a complete change of how defense has worked.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by NYCAuburn

TD Platinum Membership/SECr Sheriff

Member since Feb 2011

57002 posts

Posted on 2/26/14 at 8:06 pm to narddogg81

quote:
who ever said the d had to adhere to more rules presnap than the o?

That's the basic principle behind y'all's bitching, the advantage pre snap and equality.

quote:
the reason there are so many presnap rules on the o is because they have the ball, they know the play, they know the snap count

So there is less equality because of the fundamental aspects of the sport? Good lord that's some pussy arse football. Maybe we can all get ribbons next year