Total yards

Gerhart 1885 yards and 26 TD's after 321 touches

Ingram 1864 yards and 18 TD's after 279 touches

Ingram had to share with a team that got 2806 yds rushing on the season.

Gerhart had to share with a team that got 2692 yds rushing on the season.

This argument is basically coming down to which team you want to see have the Heisman winner on it. Most rivals here don't want Bama to get it, simply because it's Bama. Not because Gerhart is better than Ingram.

3 ...

Report Post

Posted by zeod

Member since Aug 2009

419 posts

Posted on 12/7/09 at 10:32 pm to Alahunter

Ingram carried Alabama to several victories in the SEC and ultimately lead them to an undefeated season. Herhart carried his team to victory against a bunch of scrubs and still lost games.

Ingram is the better player, on a better team and therefore deserves it more.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by St Augustine

The Pauper of the Surf

Member since Mar 2006

64658 posts

Posted on 12/7/09 at 10:32 pm to Alahunter

I could give a crap about bama getting it. I just feel that TG was clearly the focus of the opposing teams week in and week out was rarely stopped. The same can be said about MI although I feel that bama DEFINITELY had more weapons at their disposal in the passing game to take some pressure off of Ingram. In no way will I be the slightest bit disappointed if MI gets it. Anybody who pulls against a classy kid just because he plays for a rival is pussy anyway.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by msukb79