Started By
Message
QB A vs QB B - Marcel Reed & Arch Manning
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:06 pm
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:06 pm
For all the crap Aggies have given Manning for sucking, it's interesting to see how similiar our two QB's are statistically. And this is with Texas having a horrible O-line that did no favors:
QB A:
168 / 268 for 62.7% completion. 2,123 yards averaging 7.9 yards a pass 18 TD's and 6 picks.
QB B:
157 / 252 for 62.3% completion, 2,193 yards averaging 8.7 yards a pass, 19 TD's and 6 picks.
I guess they both must suck? Or they both are having decent years?
QB A:
168 / 268 for 62.7% completion. 2,123 yards averaging 7.9 yards a pass 18 TD's and 6 picks.
QB B:
157 / 252 for 62.3% completion, 2,193 yards averaging 8.7 yards a pass, 19 TD's and 6 picks.
I guess they both must suck? Or they both are having decent years?
23
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:08 pm to VYForever
Rushing stats?
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:09 pm to VYForever
Arch has played 1 more cupcake
Reed has played 1 more power 4 opponent
Most of Arch’s yards passing are passes caught behind the line of scrimmage
Also Arch represents most of Utrans offense since they can’t run
Reed has played 1 more power 4 opponent
Most of Arch’s yards passing are passes caught behind the line of scrimmage
Also Arch represents most of Utrans offense since they can’t run
This post was edited on 11/9/25 at 10:11 pm
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:10 pm to VYForever
Are we making wagers on how long it takes for dildos to get posted in this thread?
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:11 pm to FAT SEXY
Marge has already posted once and refrained which is quite remarkable for her standards.
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:12 pm to FAT SEXY
Just a typical Utrans fan being upset his big brother is ranked higher
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:13 pm to VYForever
Wow and this is Reed's 2nd year as a starter, very interesting
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:15 pm to FAT SEXY
Manning: 146.9 rating, 69 carries for 203 yards, GREATEST QB EVA
Reed: 155.5 rating, 69 carries for 378 yards, projected to be bottom half of SEC QBs
In short, Reed is a better passer than Manning, a better runner than Manning, and has exceeded all expectations.
Reed: 155.5 rating, 69 carries for 378 yards, projected to be bottom half of SEC QBs
In short, Reed is a better passer than Manning, a better runner than Manning, and has exceeded all expectations.
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:16 pm to Hugh McElroy
Reed - 69 rushes, 378 yards, 6 TD's
Manning - 69, 203 yards, 6 TD's
Overall A&M has over 1800 yards rushing to Texas' 1218.
Reed's 378 accounts for ~20% of Aggy's rush offense
Mannings 203 accounts for ~17% of Longhorns rush offense
Manning - 69, 203 yards, 6 TD's
Overall A&M has over 1800 yards rushing to Texas' 1218.
Reed's 378 accounts for ~20% of Aggy's rush offense
Mannings 203 accounts for ~17% of Longhorns rush offense
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:17 pm to tBrand
Manning played in 10 games last year
Reed was the backup to start and played in 8 games
Reed was the backup to start and played in 8 games
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:17 pm to VYForever
QB A:
Hyped up as the best QB prospect of all time…
…which he is not.
QB B:
Projected as a solid P5 QB…
…which he is.
Hyped up as the best QB prospect of all time…
…which he is not.
QB B:
Projected as a solid P5 QB…
…which he is.
This post was edited on 11/9/25 at 10:25 pm
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:18 pm to VYForever
Now take out one of your cupcake games
Or agree to reassess after we play Samford
You’ve lost this one badly
Or agree to reassess after we play Samford
You’ve lost this one badly
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:19 pm to Hugh McElroy
quote:
In short, Reed is a better passer than Manning, a better runner than Manning, and has exceeded all expectations.
Look, nobody is denying this.
However, if you are going to say Reed is good, average or acceptable as a starting QB in the SEC you cannot then in the next breath say Manning is the worst QB in the league and is trash and the book on him is written. That's the point I'm making with comparing statistics.
The fact that Reed is good and lead A&M to where it is this year is what I'm benchmarking Manning against. I'm not trying to make a case that Reed isn't good or his stats are trash.
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:19 pm to VYForever
Only stat that really matters…
Temu: 2 losses
Marcel: 0 losses
Temu: 2 losses
Marcel: 0 losses
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:20 pm to VYForever
quote:
if you are going to say Reed is good, average or acceptable as a starting QB in the SEC you cannot then in the next breath say Manning is the worst QB in the league and is trash and the book on him is written.
Fair enough.
Edit: It would be interesting to see the comparison again on the Monday of Thanksgiving week.
This post was edited on 11/9/25 at 10:22 pm
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:21 pm to Old Sarge
For sure the ultimate comparison is going to be at the end of the year. A&M has clearly had the better season and better QB play up to this point in the season.
The fact that you people are so knee-jerk defensive as to miss the forest from the trees on a consistent basis is puzzling to me. How do you people keep a job where you have to communicate and work with other people?
The fact that you people are so knee-jerk defensive as to miss the forest from the trees on a consistent basis is puzzling to me. How do you people keep a job where you have to communicate and work with other people?
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:22 pm to VYForever
quote:
in the next breath say Manning is the worst QB in the league and is trash
My TexasEx’s buddies all say this, not Aggies
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:22 pm to VYForever
I know Arch scored in College Station last year but I can’t recall if Reed did anything except get sacked and throw interceptions. 
looking forward to a good game between to evenly matched QBs this year
looking forward to a good game between to evenly matched QBs this year
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:23 pm to Old Sarge
quote:
My TexasEx’s buddies all say this, not Aggies
I've said it a lot myself. But come on, the first 6 weeks of this season had a new Arch Manning is burning thread every 5 minutes.
Posted on 11/9/25 at 10:24 pm to Old Sarge
Reed won't play many snaps against Samford
Page 1 of 4
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News