Started By
Message

Recruiting Rewind 2011-2014 ::: Top 10 Pro-Style QB's
Posted on 12/20/16 at 11:26 am
Posted on 12/20/16 at 11:26 am
These were the rankings and their school of choice upon National Signing Day.
---------- HS class of 2011 ----------
# 1 Jeff Driskel -- 4 Stars @ Florida
# 2 Cody Kessler -- 4 Stars @ USC
# 3 Max Wittek -- 4 Stars @ USC
# 4 Christian LeMay -- 4 Stars @ Georgia
# 5 Brandon Allen -- 4 Stars @ Arkansas
# 6 David Ash -- 3 Stars @ Texas
# 7 Kyle Boehm -- 3 Stars @ California
# 8 Reilly O'Toole -- 3 Stars @ Illinois
# 9 Tony McNeal -- 3 Stars @ Clemson
# 10 Chad Jeffries -- 3 Stars @ San Diego State
---------- HS class of 2012 ----------
# 1 Gunner Kiel -- 5 Stars @ Notre Dame
# 2 Zach Kline -- 4 Stars @ California
# 3 Tanner Mangum -- 4 Stars @ Brigham Young
# 4 Chad Voytik -- 4 Stars @ Pittsburgh
# 5 Jake Rodrigues -- 4 Stars @ Oregon
# 6 Tyler Matthews -- 4 Stars @ TCU
# 7 Wes Lunt -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma State
# 8 Nathan Peterman -- 4 Stars @ Tennessee
# 9 Patrick Towles -- 4 Stars @ Kentucky
# 10 Connor Brewer -- 4 Stars @ Texas
---------- HS class of 2013 ----------
# 1 Max Browne -- 5 Stars @ USC
# 2 Christian Hackenberg -- 5 Stars @ Penn State
# 3 Hayden Rettig -- 4 Stars @ LSU
# 4 Shane Morris -- 4 Stars @ Michigan
# 5 Jeremy Johnson -- 4 Stars @ Auburn
# 6 Ryan Burns -- 4 Stars @ Stanford
# 7 Cody Thomas -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma
# 8 Jared Goff -- 4 Stars @ California
# 9 Danny Etling -- 4 Stars @ Purdue
# 10 Bucky Hodges -- 4 Stars @ Virginia Tech
---------- HS class of 2014 ----------
# 1 Kyle Allen -- 5 Stars @ Texas A&M
# 2 Keller Chryst -- 4 Stars @ Stanford
# 3 David Cornwell -- 4 Stars @ Alabama
# 4 Sean White -- 4 Stars @ Auburn
# 5 Drew Barker -- 4 Stars @ Kentucky
# 6 Justice Hansen -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma
# 7 Michael O'Connor -- 4 Stars @ Penn State
# 8 Brad Kaaya -- 4 Stars @ Miami (FL)
# 9 Mason Rudolph -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma State
# 10 K.J. Carta-Samuels -- 4 Stars @ Washington
---------- HS class of 2011 ----------
# 1 Jeff Driskel -- 4 Stars @ Florida
# 2 Cody Kessler -- 4 Stars @ USC
# 3 Max Wittek -- 4 Stars @ USC
# 4 Christian LeMay -- 4 Stars @ Georgia
# 5 Brandon Allen -- 4 Stars @ Arkansas
# 6 David Ash -- 3 Stars @ Texas
# 7 Kyle Boehm -- 3 Stars @ California
# 8 Reilly O'Toole -- 3 Stars @ Illinois
# 9 Tony McNeal -- 3 Stars @ Clemson
# 10 Chad Jeffries -- 3 Stars @ San Diego State
---------- HS class of 2012 ----------
# 1 Gunner Kiel -- 5 Stars @ Notre Dame
# 2 Zach Kline -- 4 Stars @ California
# 3 Tanner Mangum -- 4 Stars @ Brigham Young
# 4 Chad Voytik -- 4 Stars @ Pittsburgh
# 5 Jake Rodrigues -- 4 Stars @ Oregon
# 6 Tyler Matthews -- 4 Stars @ TCU
# 7 Wes Lunt -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma State
# 8 Nathan Peterman -- 4 Stars @ Tennessee
# 9 Patrick Towles -- 4 Stars @ Kentucky
# 10 Connor Brewer -- 4 Stars @ Texas
---------- HS class of 2013 ----------
# 1 Max Browne -- 5 Stars @ USC
# 2 Christian Hackenberg -- 5 Stars @ Penn State
# 3 Hayden Rettig -- 4 Stars @ LSU
# 4 Shane Morris -- 4 Stars @ Michigan
# 5 Jeremy Johnson -- 4 Stars @ Auburn
# 6 Ryan Burns -- 4 Stars @ Stanford
# 7 Cody Thomas -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma
# 8 Jared Goff -- 4 Stars @ California
# 9 Danny Etling -- 4 Stars @ Purdue
# 10 Bucky Hodges -- 4 Stars @ Virginia Tech
---------- HS class of 2014 ----------
# 1 Kyle Allen -- 5 Stars @ Texas A&M
# 2 Keller Chryst -- 4 Stars @ Stanford
# 3 David Cornwell -- 4 Stars @ Alabama
# 4 Sean White -- 4 Stars @ Auburn
# 5 Drew Barker -- 4 Stars @ Kentucky
# 6 Justice Hansen -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma
# 7 Michael O'Connor -- 4 Stars @ Penn State
# 8 Brad Kaaya -- 4 Stars @ Miami (FL)
# 9 Mason Rudolph -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma State
# 10 K.J. Carta-Samuels -- 4 Stars @ Washington
Posted on 12/20/16 at 11:33 am to HoustonGumbeauxGuy
Busts everywhere
Posted on 12/20/16 at 11:38 am to RLDSC FAN
quote:
Busts everywhere
That's being fricking kind.

I count one first round draft pick in Goff (who looks terrible) and another potential one in Kaaya.
Horrible.
Posted on 12/20/16 at 11:57 am to HoustonGumbeauxGuy
man a lot of misfires
Posted on 12/20/16 at 2:07 pm to HoustonGumbeauxGuy
quote:
# 2 Christian Hackenberg -- 5 Stars @ Penn State
I've never been more wrong about a prospect. Thought he was gonna be elite.
Posted on 12/20/16 at 2:11 pm to RLDSC FAN
quote:
Busts everywhere
We have a long way to go when it comes to evaluating QB prospects.
The Dual Threat list was way better than this.
Posted on 12/20/16 at 2:15 pm to HoustonGumbeauxGuy
quote:
---------- HS class of 2012 ----------
# 1 Gunner Kiel -- 5 Stars @ Notre Dame
# 2 Zach Kline -- 4 Stars @ California
# 3 Tanner Mangum -- 4 Stars @ Brigham Young
# 4 Chad Voytik -- 4 Stars @ Pittsburgh
# 5 Jake Rodrigues -- 4 Stars @ Oregon
# 6 Tyler Matthews -- 4 Stars @ TCU
# 7 Wes Lunt -- 4 Stars @ Oklahoma State
# 8 Nathan Peterman -- 4 Stars @ Tennessee
# 9 Patrick Towles -- 4 Stars @ Kentucky
# 10 Connor Brewer -- 4 Stars @ Texas
Tanner Mangum is the only top 10 QB from 2012 who didn't transfer

And even he didn't start playing for BYU until 2015...
Posted on 12/20/16 at 3:38 pm to TideSaint
QB evaluation in HS is exceptionally terrible. The funny thing is that services love to hype QB prospects up as top overall recruits, knowing damn well history shows that only one of their top 5 will be worth a damn.
Posted on 12/20/16 at 4:22 pm to HoustonGumbeauxGuy
quote:
# 1 Gunner Kiel -- 5 Stars @ Notre Dame
Chest
Posted on 12/20/16 at 4:43 pm to Socratics
quote:
We have a long way to go when it comes to evaluating QB prospects.
Should probably rank the good kickers as 5* and every single QB a 2 or 3, based off these lists.
Popular
Back to top
