Started By
Message
re: SEC Office: 44% of the erroneous calls in the UGA/AU game went in Auburn’s favor
Posted on 10/24/25 at 7:23 pm to DawgsLife
Posted on 10/24/25 at 7:23 pm to DawgsLife
quote:
what difference does it make?
Do you really not see the importance of a coach that calls a timeout then lies about it to the ref to have it refunded?
1
Posted on 10/24/25 at 7:27 pm to AlextheBodacious
Damn. Nice to meet the guy that had the balls dumped in his face. You’ve been carrying this burden for too long.
Posted on 10/24/25 at 7:52 pm to Tuscaloosa
Let's say each team ran 75 plays and there were 9 mistakes. How would you like it if your Pharmacist got you the right medication 94% of the time?
Posted on 10/24/25 at 8:24 pm to HillabeeBaw
quote:
The Gumps seem to forgst that Georgia shut them down in the 2nd half. But, but, but that's different!
Imagine being this retarded. Wow.
Posted on 10/24/25 at 8:27 pm to Bama3714
quote:
The worst call in that game was the make-up call that went against Uga immediately after the Kirby timeout fiasco. I can't remember if it was a holding or personal foul, but I just remember that whatever it was was completely ridiculous.
It was a blindside block that took away a large gain, maybe even a TD.
Posted on 10/24/25 at 9:12 pm to msutiger
quote:
Not all plays are of equal importance
True. Its possible the 4 bad for one team are worse than the 5 bad for the other.
Posted on 10/24/25 at 10:01 pm to Gator5220
Overturned by SEC office
3rd and Goal - TD (incorrect call)
4th and Goal - Defense lined up in
Neutral Zone (not called)
4th and Goal - TD (incorrect call)
Pass interference against Auburn 2nd quarter on a third down -(no penalty should have been called)
Roughing the passer against Auburn - (no penalty should’ve been called)
Targeting against Georgia -not called/(targeting should’ve been called )
Timeout- forced to use last timeout or delay of game
Upheld by SEC office
Review of catch by Georgia /targeting against Auburn (correct call)
Georgia QB on blindside block TD was over the line of scrimmage. QB was at line of scrimmage (no call on being past line of scrimmage) (correct call)
3rd and Goal - TD (incorrect call)
4th and Goal - Defense lined up in
Neutral Zone (not called)
4th and Goal - TD (incorrect call)
Pass interference against Auburn 2nd quarter on a third down -(no penalty should have been called)
Roughing the passer against Auburn - (no penalty should’ve been called)
Targeting against Georgia -not called/(targeting should’ve been called )
Timeout- forced to use last timeout or delay of game
Upheld by SEC office
Review of catch by Georgia /targeting against Auburn (correct call)
Georgia QB on blindside block TD was over the line of scrimmage. QB was at line of scrimmage (no call on being past line of scrimmage) (correct call)
Posted on 10/25/25 at 12:38 am to msutiger
quote:
Not all plays are of equal importance
I'd be interested to know if the actual replay is one of them. The NFL TV ref for ABC felt the ball didn't break the plane when he reviewed the call, (not the TV ref doing the game with Herbstreit and McDonough).
When you're saying not all are the same: Kirby's timeout had little effect. Georgia kicked and missed a FG on that drive and they called our rb for a blindside block when he was clearly in front of and should have been seen by the defender.
Just my thought. The Kirby "clap" out was probably the biggest blunder even though it had little effect on the outcome. There's just nothing that allows the refs to do a "do over". Either they have to penalize Auburn for delay of game or charge Kirby for a timeout.
Honestly, that's probably three missed calls or errors due to one play. They missed the clapping call on Auburn, they didn't charge Kirby with a timeout, and the subsequent play led to a blindside block call that was erroneous.
I have seen many calls reversed or upheld on replay that were more obvious than the goal line situation. The error there is that if they didn't blow a whistle the ball was live and Georgia should have had a touchdown.
I would also bet there are games with more than nine missed calls. The problem is this got major media coverage and they probably felt the had to do something.
I still look back at the safety on Hooker at the UT/UGA game in 2022 as the worst call I've ever seen after replay review. The offensive lineman would've had to have been levetating for it not to be a safety, as his knee was cleary down before he got the ball out of the EZ.
Posted on 10/26/25 at 1:05 pm to Gator5220
quote:
Do you really not see the importance of a coach that calls a timeout then lies about it to the ref to have it refunded?
Are you joking? No. You're serious. You honestly believe every time a coach yells his team's wide receiver caught the ball (even though it is obvious the ball was trapped) that he honestly believes his receiver caught the ball? Or, that when a holding penalty is called on one of his OLinemen and he screams he wasn't holding he believes it? They all think PI against their team never happens but when their own receiver does not catch the ball the DB interfered?
Hint. Coaches lie to referees all the time in an effort to get them to reverse calls. Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't.
Riiiiight.
Posted on 10/26/25 at 2:38 pm to DawgsLife
Reading isn't your strong suit, is it? I'm not talking about other calls or the impact or any of the other things you keep deflecting to.
Just say you don't see it as a big deal that a coach would call a timeout with 1 second left then lies about it to not only get it refunded but reset the play clock to 25 seconds.
Pay attention and try to stay on point.
Just say you don't see it as a big deal that a coach would call a timeout with 1 second left then lies about it to not only get it refunded but reset the play clock to 25 seconds.
Pay attention and try to stay on point.
Posted on 10/27/25 at 2:27 pm to Gator5220
quote:
call a timeout with 1 second left
So...you can lie but a coach cannot?
And you just deflected. is it ok for a coach to claim his receiver caught a pass when it clearly was trapped, or not? Dude. get over it. Georgia did not use the timeout.
Coaches argue and try to change referee calls all the time in every single game fully knowing the call was correct.
Now...let's put it to rest. Kirby was not saying he was clapping...he was saying the Auburn Safety was clapping and there should be a penalty. Yes, I agree Kirby did signal for a timeout, but his point was that he should not have to call a timeout to get them to call a penalty on Auburn. If you see a full picture the safety for Auburn was clearly clapping his hands. Kirby clearly points at the safety and says he was clapping....not "I was clapping" as all you pearl clutchers keep claiming. There were a ton of calls made in the game that were don poorly, but for you to choose this one is crazy.
This post was edited on 10/27/25 at 2:35 pm
Posted on 10/27/25 at 5:05 pm to DawgsLife
Page 5 of 5
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News