re: Miami '01 vs Alabama '09

quote:

---

04 AU vs. 09 Bama would be epic.

AU in a close one, though.

---

No, AU would have won by double digits.

And about the LSU game, LSU was the defending national champs that had not allowed a TD in about 15 quarters when they played AU. And it was an extra point that would have meant the game stayed tied that LSU was penalized on. LSU was the only team all year that even gave AU a game. Not only did we never trail all year in the 4th, we were beating every team by double digits until Tubs went into a shell and ran up the middle every play. That AU team could have named the score against about anyone they played all year. Hell we would blow everyone out until the 3rd, then just sit on it. Even in the SECCG, we went up about 20 on UT then sat on it. Against VT, 16-0 starting the 4th and probably could have won by more if not for the Tubbershell.

'09 Bama beats '04 Auburn in a close one. I think Bama's D stops Aubs run and Jason Campbell loses his composure and costs AU the game.

quote:

---

No, AU would have won by double digits

---

Prove it.

So now the quality of a team is decided by when they score rather than the final score?

You don't get it, do you Hunter? All of those criteria are only applicable to the year in which the team played, and cannot validly be compared across years.

It isn't that difficult of a concept but you seem to have a hard time grasping it. This doesn't surprise me, however.

Comparing teams across years is a qualitative inquiry, based on individual perceptions.

Auburn put a shitload of talent into the NFL from that team. Could Alabama match that in the future? Possibly. Maybe.

But, to me, at the critical positions, I see an advantage in Auburn's personnel at nearly every one. Quarterback. Running back (OK that one is close). Defensive line. Secondary.

quote:

---

You fail, again.

---

Your entire existence is a failure, hunter.

TxTiger... You are the one that doesn't get it. While they may or may not have had more talent... they did not produce. You cannot use their abilities post college to make the argument in their college play. Continue with your failed attempts to justify a losing proposition though. It only adds to the insult and injury that you have self inflicted upon yourself this past season, with your lack of knowledge.

quote:

---

they did not produce.

---

They went undefeated, Hunter. You can't "produce" any more than that.

quote:

---

You cannot use their abilities post college to make the argument in their college play.

---

Valid point, but I think their players were better in college than Alabama's players. Its my personal opinion.

quote:

---

with your lack of knowledge.

---

I've forgotten more than you'll ever know.

quote:

---

Then what is it that you are using to come up with the opinion that AU would beat UA?

---

I explained it in the same post. Read more carefully.

quote:

---

They went undefeated, Hunter. You can't "produce" any more than that

---

So did Bama.. against higher ranked teams.

quote:

---

Valid point, but I think their players were better in college than Alabama's players. Its my personal opinion.

---

Yet they didn't produce more than Bama did in their respective years.

quote:

---

I've forgotten more than you'll ever know.

---

Son... you never knew what you thought you did.

should i have added.. of a bitch?