Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message
locked post

From an old HS coach’s perspective

Posted on 11/16/25 at 10:49 am
Posted by cmayes56
Alabama
Member since Oct 2015
3090 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 10:49 am
SEC Grades and Review:

Georgia:

Gunter Stockton was lights out last night. 24/29 229 yards, 4 TDS and 1 rushing.

The defense was salty in the trenches.. they gave up just 23 yards on the ground total.

Dominating performance in all phases of the game.

Grade: A+

Texas:

They found out what a Saturday night in Athens Georgia feels like… Arch didn’t play horrible.. 251 yds, 1 TD 1 INT. He had no running game (it matters) and was sacked 3 times.

The defense was gashed.. and Texas is pretty stout on the edges and in the back end. But they weren’t last night. They got ambushed.

Grade: D-

LSU: they won so that matters most, but they didn’t play well. But they put together a 92 yard drive at the end to win the game so kudos are in order.

Grade: B-

Arkansas:

They find ways to lose.. had 3 possessions inside LSU 10 yard line and managed 7 pts. Of course Bobby elected to go for two 4th downs instead of kicking chip shot fgs.. they lost by 1?????

Bobby needs to get his motorcycle back out.. he can wreck it too.

Grade: F

Ole Miss:

They struggled early but got it going in the 2nd half.. Lane does a good job and barring a collapse they’re a playoff team.

Grade: B

Florida:

The talent, especially on defense is obvious. But this is not a good team. Lagway hasn’t lived up to his preseason hype. But they keep playing hard and in today’s atmosphere in college football that counts for something.

Grade: D+

Texas A&M:

Down 27 at the half??.. that’s not great to say the least. Coming back to take the lead with 10 minutes to go in game says a lot about the chemistry of this team.

When Reed gets in going, he’s as good as any QB in the country and they have weapons everywhere.

The defense is nasty up front and they make plays. But all that doesn’t erase the first half. Coming back against SC isn’t the same as doing it against a top tier team.

Grade: B+

South Carolina:

Great first half, but it’s a 60 minute game. They continue to lose games they probably should win.

But at least the 2 players that got forearmed shivered in the tunnel handled that situation well. In my opinion the State Trooper should be charged with assault.

Grade: D

Oklahoma:

Their front 7 is as good as there is in college football. They create havoc, play with abandon and will hit your butt. The secondary is the weak link.. and they were yesterday. Gave up over 300 in the air.. But the Defense is why they won the game.

Defense travels and when they give the offense the ball twice inside the opponents 30.. have a pick six.. you usually win.

Offensively, they aren’t anything special. They didn’t play very well.. all year or yesterday.

Special teams is fantastic:

Grade: B+

Alabama:

Where do we start? ??

If you chop the bottom lines off the stat sheet you’d say they won by double digits. But that’s not how the game works. Pilling up yardage is great.. but you have to finish drives.

The defense played lights out and kept them in the game. When your opponents avg starting field position is their own 44 yard line, and 3 drives started inside your 30 yard line.. only giving up 23 points is winning football.

Kicking game is ungood.

Grade: C- (only because the defense kept them in the game)

Final review:

Georgia looks like they may be the best team in the league.. at least last night. Played their most complete game..

Texas A&M has benefited from playing the bottom 7 teams in the SEC so I’m not completely sold on them yet

Oklahoma is salty but it wouldn’t surprise me if they drop one of their last two..

Alabama is still a really good team but if they don’t clean up ball security, protection they could lose at Auburn and flush the season.

Everyone blames Ty Simpson and he definitely has to shoulder a big portion of the blame. But through 10 games.. Ty and the receivers have had to carry this offense.

I said 2 weeks ago I didn’t think they would get out of November unbeaten.

The running game was a little better yesterday, they actually had ONE run for over 10 yards… ONE!!!

The inability to keep a defense like Oklahoma honest with a run threat means your QB etc has to play perfect. Well they weren’t perfect and they lost because of it.

Overview:

If Alabama can manage to survive Auburn.. they go to Atlanta to face either Texas A&M or Georgia. There’s no scenario that changes that.

If they don’t survive Auburn.. none of it matters and it’s another season of playing in a meaningless bowl game.

So for both Texas A&M and Alabama.. it’s a one game regular season. Beat Texas and beat Auburn.. meet in Atlanta.

If Either one of them lose… Georgia is going to be there waiting for someone and I don’t think anyone wants to see them .
Posted by DivePlay
Member since Sep 2012
1193 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 10:59 am to
So a team you gave a D to with an interim coach leads most of the game against a team you gave a B+ ?

Thanks for proving most coaches are retarded members of society.
Posted by cmayes56
Alabama
Member since Oct 2015
3090 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 11:00 am to
Who wins matters.. it’s a 60 minute game
Posted by DivePlay
Member since Sep 2012
1193 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 11:06 am to
Of course it matters, brilliant take.

The fact that the #7 team in the country barely escaped a garbage unranked team with no real coach also matters.
Posted by memphisRebel
Memphis, TN
Member since Jan 2013
489 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 11:20 am to
quote:

So a team you gave a D to with an interim coach leads most of the game against a team you gave a B+ ? Thanks for proving most coaches are retarded members of society


But you have a humongously huge stadium, a gazilliony NIL dollars, every 5-star recruit within 5 minutes of campus, a statue of Spurrier, a statue of Tebow, alumni with bizzillions of dollars and the garden city of Gainesville.
How could you possibly lose to a bunch of hicks with 15 tailgaters, a stadium that seats dozens, a poverty NIL budget and no running water?

Did I get all of that right?

And my late dad was a HS football coach, so go frick yourself!
This post was edited on 11/16/25 at 11:34 am
Posted by cmayes56
Alabama
Member since Oct 2015
3090 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 2:37 pm to
So what grade would assign Coach Lombardi?

A+ because you hung in there with an interim coach? B+ because you lost at home?

I’m just an old ball coach that gave my assessment…

Florida made some B’s early but ultimately bombed on the final.. that final is the score that counts
Posted by Gunga Din
Oklahoma
Member since Jul 2020
3086 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 3:02 pm to
quote:

Thanks for proving most coaches are retarded members of society.


That is kind of harsh... but I bet this guy does make shopping center appearances as Captain Obvious... as his retirement gig.
Posted by Lonnie Utah
Utah!
Member since Jul 2012
31948 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 3:34 pm to
Come on. SC is a SOLID C-.....
Posted by Chad4Bama
Member since Sep 2020
8328 posts
Posted on 11/16/25 at 4:09 pm to
Good analysis.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter