Posted by
Message
GalvoAg
Texas A&M Fan
Galveston TX
Member since Apr 2012
10794 posts

re: Beckham is MORE talented than Evans
I would take him over Beckham as a WR, which is all that matters.


TeamLSU
LSU Fan
Member since Feb 2009
2610 posts

Fair enough. I would take the more COMPLETE FOOTBALL player, which is all that matters.


CrimsonPride
Alabama Fan
Houston, Tx
Member since Oct 2013
400 posts

quote:

Fair enough. I would take the more COMPLETE FOOTBALL player, which is all that matters.


your an Idiot if you would take Beckham over Evans


GalvoAg
Texas A&M Fan
Galveston TX
Member since Apr 2012
10794 posts

quote:

Fair enough. I would take the more COMPLETE FOOTBALL player, which is all that matters.



Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
MMB5DAP
Texas A&M Fan
Member since Jul 2013
1710 posts

quote:

Fair enough. I would take the more COMPLETE FOOTBALL player, which is all that matters.


Who cares if he can return punts and kickoffs. Lots of people can do that. Not many WR go for almost 300 yards against 2 top 10 teams...in the same season.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
Fuegoqueso
Texas A&M Fan
Houston
Member since Oct 2013
675 posts

I dont really follow the coon asses that much. But was it this year or last year, where the recievers dropped so many passes for LSU. Beckham specifically comes to mind............

Mike Evans has been a monster the past two years. And you cant exactly say system because A&M runs a spread and LSU runs more pro-style. Last year JFF led the SEC in rushing, and A&M had two 1k yd recievers (Swope and Evans). This year Mike Evans stats are off the charts. Few receptions, yet alot of yards. And he played his best in the biggest games.


This is still a troll topic. But bottomline game on the line, who would you throw it to? Yeah I'm taking the 6'5 monster who has shown to be a jump ball wizard. Evans in term of talent >Beckham. I'd take Landry over Beckham too.
This post was edited on 11/8 at 10:21 am


randomways
Vanderbilt Fan
North Carolina
Member since Aug 2013
12988 posts

It depends on what you want, though. Beckham is definitely faster than Evans, which means Beckham can slip past lots of players (he kinda did make life difficult for Sunseri last year, iirc. You can correct me if I'm remembering wrongly.)

Actually, Sunseri's injury could be a blessing in disguise this year, at least for this particular game. He's a helluva player. I like him a lot. But his replacement (that would still be Landon Collins, right?) is faster and more athletic. He's not quite there with Vinnie in terms of experience, but he's faster and has good instincts/reactions. That helps when dealing with a receiver like Beckham,


TeamLSU
LSU Fan
Member since Feb 2009
2610 posts

So name me one thing BESIDES ht/wt that Evans has OVER Beckham. Just


MMB5DAP
Texas A&M Fan
Member since Jul 2013
1710 posts

quote:

It depends on what you want, though. Beckham is definitely faster than Evans


Dont need speed when the other players cant tackle you or out jump you.



Maybe beckham runs by this ole miss defender and gets to the 5 yard line. Evans jumps over him and drags 3 people to the 5 yard line.


MMB5DAP
Texas A&M Fan
Member since Jul 2013
1710 posts

quote:

So name me one thing BESIDES ht/wt that Evans has OVER Beckham. Just


He can jump higher and has better hands


SR SponsorSR Fan
USA
Member since 2001
Thank you for supporting our sponsors
Advertisement
randomways
Vanderbilt Fan
North Carolina
Member since Aug 2013
12988 posts

Don't get me wrong. I'd take Evans over Beckham any day of the week. I won't debate which one is "more talented" or "more complete," but Evans is definitely a more unique player. Beckham is fast and talented, but he's also a fairly generic WR. You can pick those up anywhere; players like Evans are much harder to acquire.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
TeamLSU
LSU Fan
Member since Feb 2009
2610 posts

i would take landry also, but the op is about beckham vs. evans. if u just have to have a jump ball of course take evans, but if you have to have a punt return/kickoff return Beckham ALL DAY. you see games are won in different ways. So saying you would take evans because of the potental of a jump ball, well i would take beckham because of the potential of a kick or punt return. Again, complete player


GalvoAg
Texas A&M Fan
Galveston TX
Member since Apr 2012
10794 posts

quote:

better hands

All you need to know


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
MMB5DAP
Texas A&M Fan
Member since Jul 2013
1710 posts

quote:

So saying you would take evans because of the potental of a jump ball, well i would take beckham because of the potential of a kick or punt return. Again, complete player


Seriously wtf are you talking about. Its time to pick your players: You got Devin Hester and Calvin Johnson. You're telling me you pick Hester for his punt returns.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
GalvoAg
Texas A&M Fan
Galveston TX
Member since Apr 2012
10794 posts

quote:

Again, complete player

Because he can return kicks?


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
randomways
Vanderbilt Fan
North Carolina
Member since Aug 2013
12988 posts

If we're talking about special teams, then, yeah, Beckham has more to offer. Evans would still be my choice even taking that into account because there are plenty of speedy players I could put on ST.


Of course, I'd take David Palmer over both of them and never look back.


AeroAg2012
Texas A&M Fan
Member since Sep 2012
83 posts

quote:

If you watch Evans closely he runs horrible routes.


Many, many NFL scouts disagree with you. Evans uses his strength and hands to get a clean release and is excellent about leveraging defenders and using the sideline, particularly on vertical routes. He's a much better route-runner than most college WRs and to state otherwise is delusional.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
TeamLSU
LSU Fan
Member since Feb 2009
2610 posts

i will be willing to bet when lsu plays the ags, beckham will have MORE of an IMPACT on the game than evans. just sit back and watch.


MMB5DAP
Texas A&M Fan
Member since Jul 2013
1710 posts

quote:

i will be willing to bet when lsu plays the ags, beckham will have MORE of an IMPACT on the game than evans. just sit back and watch.


Lets see every kickoff is gonna go through the end zone and we punt on average once or twice a game. Better be all receiving yards.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
Drudawg
Georgia Fan
The Ash
Member since Sep 2012
389 posts

Results > paper.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
first pageprev pagePage 4 of 5next pagelast page

Back to top

logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter