
Started By
Message
re: Would you change churches
Posted on 5/10/16 at 9:12 pm to Wtodd
Posted on 5/10/16 at 9:12 pm to Wtodd
quote:
That's quite an assumption
Given the amount of divorce and obesity found in the church, I'd say it's a safe assumption.
A church that took the same type of stance against gluttony as many take on homosexuality would find its pews bare in a hurry. The number of unapologetic gluttons in the average church is high.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 6:52 am to DynastyDawg
I still believe there is A LOT of truth in what Marx had to say on the subject:
"Religion is the opiate of the masses."
"Religion is the opiate of the masses."
Posted on 5/11/16 at 7:52 am to Roger Klarvin
quote:
Given the amount of divorce and obesity found in the church, I'd say it's a safe assumption.
A church that took the same type of stance against gluttony as many take on homosexuality would find its pews bare in a hurry. The number of unapologetic gluttons in the average church is high.
Roger I get what you're saying and there is certainly some validity to it. Walking the path that Jesus wants us to walk is a "marathon" not a sprint. I'm guilty of many things in my younger days (not saying I'm perfect now bc I'm not) that I wouldn't do now.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 8:05 am to Roger Klarvin
Roger, there are certainly points of hypocrisy to be found, greed, gluttony....but you say homosexuality and other perversions are singled out when that just isn't accurate at all. Sexual immorality of other forms does and will continue to be points of attention.
Start the same thread about a married pastor announcing he was having an affair or that he loved and watched pornography all the time and the same responses would be offered.
Start the same thread about a married pastor announcing he was having an affair or that he loved and watched pornography all the time and the same responses would be offered.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 8:07 am to Carolina_Girl
quote:
I still believe there is A LOT of truth in what Marx had to say on the subject:
"Religion is the opiate of the masses."
I never got the negative connotation of that statement. The masses need some form of social control, from a societal level down to a personal one. If religion is that for someone more power to them. If it's something else who cares, as long as there is some sort of societal cohesion.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 8:22 am to cardboardboxer
I absolutely agree. I find it odd that so many ppl find this offensive, honestly. I suppose it's all in the interpretation of not only what it says, but how it is said as well.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 8:27 am to Old Sarge
Sincere question, but what all does the Bible consider sexually immoral? And I guess when I ask that I mean the New Testament. Nothing in the Old Testament should be taken seriously when it comes to the laws of man.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 8:41 am to The Spleen
Why should nothing in the Old Testament be taken seriously?
Is murder, lying, stealing ok now?
Is murder, lying, stealing ok now?
Posted on 5/11/16 at 8:56 am to Carolina_Girl
quote:
I absolutely agree. I find it odd that so many ppl find this offensive, honestly. I suppose it's all in the interpretation of not only what it says, but how it is said as well.
Who says it matters. Marx said it to point out what he saw as the flaws in the then current system. Many people since have said it in a demeaning way to point out the groupthink of religion. The messenger actually changes how the message is received.
If there is a God in theory that entity would WANT social controls for his people. That would be the point of the religion, to keep the flock in the right field so to speak.
I think people just hate the idea of being talked down to, or that they are controlled. That is a very modern perspective, in ancient times it was an honor to be a part of something bigger.
This post was edited on 5/11/16 at 8:58 am
Posted on 5/11/16 at 9:01 am to Old Sarge
Because it is so cherry picked. In the same book that says homosexuality is immoral(Leviticus), it says some pretty archaic stuff about menstruation.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 9:27 am to The Spleen
quote:
Leviticus
But you just cherry picked this book
It's discussed in other places as well
Posted on 5/11/16 at 9:44 am to kywildcatfanone
You know being gay isn't a choice right? Pretty sure I never chose to be straight, I'm just not attracted to dudes
Posted on 5/11/16 at 9:51 am to Old Sarge
quote:
but you say homosexuality and other perversions are singled out when that just isn't accurate at all. Sexual immorality of other forms does and will continue to be points of attention.
They are "singled out" in the sense that some sins are glossed over and merely given intellectual acknowledgement. Yes, divorce and gluttony and laziness and the like are sins many struggle with at least from time to time so it's not something worth hanging around on. Just do your best. Even it churches it's socially acceptable to acknowledge such sins knowing you won't be judged harshly by most because, again, such sins are ubiquitous.
Homosexuality however is something that only a small minority of church goers struggle with, and the ones who do are rarely comfortable acknowledging it. It's thus an easy target because most Christians don't associate with many homosexuals, can easily accept any stereotype given to them and allow themselves to truly demonize the sin because they don't struggle with it at all.
This is the major difference, and because of this practicing homosexuals are seen as unrepentant while practicing gluttons are seen as "struggling". It doesn't hurt Christians to label homosexuals that way because doing so has few if any social or intellectual ramifications for them, it doesn't cause them any cognitive dissonance. Meanwhile, a divorcee for reasons other than infidelity can't very well label divorce in such a way because per God they are still married to their spouse and commit adultery every time they sleep with their new spouse. So for them we think up all sorts of excuses excuses bevause we can't very well have 30-40% of our congregations openly living in unrepentant sin. The 1% that struggle with homosexual urges however are small enough in number to tell them they must change their ways or risk hellfire.
If the Bible is truly accurate, 100%, people who got no fault divorces for trivial reasons, got remarried and continue in that way until death will be in Hell with practicing homosexuals. That's tens of millions of Christians, even many devout ones. Yet the Bible is clear, they are adulterers who will not be in Heaven.
Biblical consistency is truly dangerous for the modern church.
quote:
Start the same thread about a married pastor announcing he was having an affair or that he loved and watched pornography all the time and the same responses would be offered.
Sure, but nobody is passing laws to try and deny porn watchers the right to use the Internet. Nobody is trying to outlaw no fault divorce.
Now, what if the thread was about a pastor who divorced in the past, is now remarried and is potentially (depending on the reason for divorce) an unrepentant adulterer? 500 years ago, this was mortal sin that sent people to hell as easily as murder.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 9:55 am to Roger Klarvin
Much truth to what you posted.
Bottom line, it's a slippery slope when fallen humans get into the business of "racking and stacking" different kinds of sin according to perceived severity.
Bottom line, it's a slippery slope when fallen humans get into the business of "racking and stacking" different kinds of sin according to perceived severity.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 10:00 am to Roger Klarvin
quote:
Sure, but nobody is passing laws to try and deny porn watchers the right to use the Internet. Nobody is trying to outlaw no fault divorce
Is anyone passing laws to make being homosexual illegal? This makes no sense.
And I agreed with you on the fact that some hypocrisy clearly exists between certain sinful lifestyles
Posted on 5/11/16 at 10:03 am to Old Sarge
quote:
Why should nothing in the Old Testament be taken seriously?
Is murder, lying, stealing ok now?
I think those were covered when Jesus said the two great commandments in the new testament, love thy neighbor as thyself.
Posted on 5/11/16 at 10:09 am to Old Sarge
Homosexuality/sodomy was illegal in almost every state in the lifetime of many posters here and was still illegal into the early 2000s in some states. However, the point was directed more towards attempts to disallow gay marriage. If we were being consistent, those same states would be outlawing no fault divorce (and many other things). Besides, divorce and heterosexual infidelity does far more damage to the institution of marriage than gay or polygamous marriage does.
This post was edited on 5/11/16 at 10:10 am
Posted on 5/11/16 at 10:26 am to Roger Klarvin
Are we discussing the past or today?
are we discussing morality? States rights? Church rules? Biblical laws?
Roger, not to be picky but you are scattershooting and mixing everything in together
are we discussing morality? States rights? Church rules? Biblical laws?
Roger, not to be picky but you are scattershooting and mixing everything in together
Posted on 5/11/16 at 10:34 am to Old Sarge
It's all interwoven though, taking issues one by one and placing them in distinct boxes is exactly how such inconsistency arises
It's comfortable to place homosexuality and how we treat it in a box by itself and not discuss the ramifications those actions have on the internal consistency of everything else we do and believe.
Imagine for a second what would happen if a given denomination of Christianity chose or were forced to consistently apply scripture and social activity to every issue in the lives of its members? I assert that that denomination would almost immediately cease to exist, or at best be culturally relegated to the radical fringe of cultish belief systems.
Now don't get me wrong, few of us live our lives consistently from one issue to the next. We don't treat our kids consistently across both sexes and all issues, we don't apply the same morals in our home and work lives, we don't apply appropriate value to the things in our lives, etc. We are inherently illogical creatures. HOWEVER, only religion claims that its inconsistency is divinely inspired.
It's comfortable to place homosexuality and how we treat it in a box by itself and not discuss the ramifications those actions have on the internal consistency of everything else we do and believe.
Imagine for a second what would happen if a given denomination of Christianity chose or were forced to consistently apply scripture and social activity to every issue in the lives of its members? I assert that that denomination would almost immediately cease to exist, or at best be culturally relegated to the radical fringe of cultish belief systems.
Now don't get me wrong, few of us live our lives consistently from one issue to the next. We don't treat our kids consistently across both sexes and all issues, we don't apply the same morals in our home and work lives, we don't apply appropriate value to the things in our lives, etc. We are inherently illogical creatures. HOWEVER, only religion claims that its inconsistency is divinely inspired.
This post was edited on 5/11/16 at 10:35 am

Popular
Back to top



2






