
Started By
Message
re: I predict religion will be completely non-existent within the next 500 years
Posted on 1/24/16 at 12:54 pm to Roger Klarvin
Posted on 1/24/16 at 12:54 pm to Roger Klarvin
From a on atheists perspective it is 100% relevant to the theory of evolution.
I understand your path here, do I believe that an alien or space traveling race dropped off that single cell? And that that single cell developed into all forms of plant and animal life on its own without intervention? I don't believe that either. Do you? Or do you choose to only believe in bits and pieces of evolution theory vs the core principles?
I understand your path here, do I believe that an alien or space traveling race dropped off that single cell? And that that single cell developed into all forms of plant and animal life on its own without intervention? I don't believe that either. Do you? Or do you choose to only believe in bits and pieces of evolution theory vs the core principles?
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:11 pm to Carolina_Girl
quote:
I have a hard time believing in a book written by humans vs. science. I WANT to believe bc of my 7 month old who died, but I just don't know. Why would a loving God take a baby from his mother? Makes zero sense to me. It pisses the hell out of me. If it means hell for me, I truly believe it cannot be any worse than losing him.
God bless you CG. What a painful scar to live with. I remember you sharing this with us before and my heart still goes out to you.
I thought a good deal about your post during church today and even discussed the broad picture of it with the youth group I was leading in SS.
My belief, or opinion? That your child is in heaven now. And you have 2 choices left to you.
1. You choose to believe that you and your child were nothing more than flesh wrapped around bone and all of your feelings for your child, all of your emotions are absolutely nothing more meaningful that chemicals interacting and electrical impulses in the complex organ which is your brain. Nothing more. Therefore there is no creator to be angry with or question is there? And your grief and anger is nothing more than what you have programmed yourself to experience.
2. You were lovingly created as was your child by a creator that knows you intimately. All your grief and even anger over the memory of your child is much deeper that random chemicals reacting in your brain, but spiritual; that a living spiritual connection exists between your child that not was but IS alive just not on this earth. Now with regard to your grief and anger with God, you are seperated from your child now on this earth. IF you are wrong about the existence of God are you not willingly forfeiting the opportunity for an eventual reunion with your child? Are you not risking an eternity of knowing your child is in a place that you can't be?
Where is the risk for you in seeking God and reconciliation with Him?
All of the above I express in love and sincere empathy CG
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:16 pm to Old Sarge
quote:
Many choose through rationalization or intellectual reasoning to do this. The question only you or God can answer is whether or not you ever truly made this decision at a spiritual level. Whether you chose to try and live a Godly life or not doesn't mean you had a relationship with Him, what does your heart tell you now? Let me ask you this. How can you question Gods existence if you ever had a truly personal relationship with Him? It would be like denying a grandparent we loved and spent time with ever really lived after they passed away. Simply because we couldn't see them or physically touch them anymore.
Would be hard to convince me I simply "wasn't saved". But we'll never know until it's time I guess.
The reason I know my grandparents are real is because I remember seeing them and doing things with them.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:19 pm to Stacked
quote:
The reason I know my grandparents are real is because I remember seeing them and doing things with them.
And I continue to see and do things with God. I don't simply choose to believe in Him.
How did you "know" you were saved? Please be as specific as possible
This post was edited on 1/24/16 at 1:20 pm
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:20 pm to Old Sarge
quote:
From a on atheists perspective it is 100% relevant to the theory of evolution.
I understand your path here, do I believe that an alien or space traveling race dropped off that single cell? And that that single cell developed into all forms of plant and animal life on its own without intervention? I don't believe that either. Do you? Or do you choose to only believe in bits and pieces of evolution theory vs the core principles?
Evolution isn't a worldview or a life philosophy, it just is what it is. Lots of Christians accept evolution in its entirity, which tells you how irrelevant the origin of life is to the truth of descent with modification.
There isn't an atheist or theist view of evolution, there's just evolution. People on both sides may try and attach philosophical worldviews to it but there isn't inherently any theological implication of evolution. Many theists in particular try to dishonestly attached the unsubstantiated idea of abiogenesis to evolution in order to say "HAH, you can't prove evolution". Only by incorporating origins with evolution can they refute it.
I accept the reality of evolution and I also seriously doubt the existence of God, and those beliefs are entirely seperate. I don't reject Christianity because of evolution.
This post was edited on 1/24/16 at 1:22 pm
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:26 pm to Roger Klarvin
Roger, evolution as a whole is just a theory. And it's clear you believe in parts of the theory but not all of the theory.
It's a good theory and if you don't believe in a creator it fills in gaps to help you feel more comfortable.
It's a good theory and if you don't believe in a creator it fills in gaps to help you feel more comfortable.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:27 pm to Old Sarge
Seeing God and seeing the effects (or affects, I can never remember which one's right) are two different things. I don't believe anybody sees God.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:27 pm to Stacked
So the difference between God and my grandparents is I could see one and in the other I just had to believe.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:29 pm to Roger Klarvin
quote:
Only by incorporating origins with evolution can they refute it.
This just isn't true Roger, the fossil record has enormous gaps in it, it is a theory because it can't be proven.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:30 pm to Stacked
I am talking about experiencing God. Can you answer my question?
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:33 pm to Old Sarge
quote:
And I continue to see and do things with God. I don't simply choose to believe in Him.
This argument always sounds compelling in a vacuum, but once you step outside the box and realize that Muslims (for example) say and genuinely believe the EXACT same thing it loses most of its punch.
It's actually pretty interesting to me how, in medicine, we consider people claiming to hear the voice of the Devil telling them to kill someone or the voice of God telling them to give away all their money, drive to Montana and live as a hermit overtly psychotic. However, if you say you GENUINELY BELIEVE you hear the voice of God telling you to do something considered socially normal like sell your house or start going to church, you're just religious.
It says a lot how unreliable human perception is and how our concepts of "normal" effect us psychologically. If I told a psychiatrists in America that Vishnu was talking to me he would want to treat me. A psychiatrist in India? Not so much.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:35 pm to Old Sarge
quote:
It's a good theory and if you don't believe in a creator it fills in gaps to help you feel more comfortable.
That doesn't make any sense LOL. But I understand what you are attempting to do. You dont like it when people point out that you need a belief in God and heaven because you fear death. So you try to take this insecurity and turn it around on intellects by saying it is them that need to feel more comfortable. Sarge has tried to do this several times though out his posts for those keeping track. Its pretty funny to watch.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:35 pm to Stacked
This thread is like the Breakfast Club of belief systems.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:35 pm to Old Sarge
I'll try. Gonna take a bit. Just put in an order at 5 guys.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:38 pm to BlackPawnMartyr
BPM, a man that believes in nothing but simple minded attacks and childish behavior.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:39 pm to Stacked
That's a pretty safe prediction,If we stay on our current path,the cockroaches are gonna own the place,and they aren't very religious..as far as I know.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:41 pm to Roger Klarvin
Don't judge me
But in all seriousness; like you or anyone else, I only truly have 1st hand knowledge of my own personal experience.
If I ate an apple this morning, you couldn't tell me anything about what my experience was in eating that apple. The best you could do is try to relate to it by recalling the last time you ate an apple. But it would be anything but my experience eating an apple this morning.
But in all seriousness; like you or anyone else, I only truly have 1st hand knowledge of my own personal experience.
If I ate an apple this morning, you couldn't tell me anything about what my experience was in eating that apple. The best you could do is try to relate to it by recalling the last time you ate an apple. But it would be anything but my experience eating an apple this morning.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:42 pm to Old Sarge
LoL pointing out what is obvious isnt simple or childish. However, calling someone childish and simple is a simple minded attack. I love your hypocrisy. 
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:45 pm to Old Sarge
quote:
the fossil record has enormous gaps in it
The gaps are "enormous" only if you believe evolution proceeds throughly distinctly different forms from one species to another, which is a misunderstanding of evolution. No life form in the history of the world has ever had an offspring that wasnt nearly identical to it. The change is do gradual that you have to look on the orders of millions of years to find distinctly different forms.
Look at humans, anatomically modern man has remained essentially the same for 200 thousand years and will continue to so for thousands of generations to come.
In that context, it is no surprise that on such large time scales we have large leaps in forms in some instances due to fossils being lost to time. It's actually exceedingly rare that a fossil is deposited in such a state as to be both preserved for that amount of time and be in a location accessible to typical human discovery.
And besides, nothing about the fossils we do have makes sense outside the light of evolution.
quote:
it is a theory because it can't be proven.
It's a theory in the same way gravity is a theory, except we know a lot more about evolution than gravity.
The Christians who reject it do so only because they believe it conflicts with their theology, not because there is any good scientific reason to do so. Christians don't deny atomic theory or the theory of gravity or the microbe theory of disease because, despite all being "theories" just like evolution, they don't see them as conflicting with their beliefs.
If the Bible said disease was caused by hamsters, Christians would deny bacteria and viruses cause disease.
Posted on 1/24/16 at 1:52 pm to Roger Klarvin
Gravity can be demonstrated and recreated. Cmon Roger you can do better.
Hamsters? So your new course for the discussion is crazy attacks on the bible or Christians?
Hamsters? So your new course for the discussion is crazy attacks on the bible or Christians?

Popular
Back to top



1






