Started By
Message

re: Down Syndrome heading for extinction in Denmark. 98% were aborted last year.

Posted on 3/23/16 at 7:28 pm to
Posted by pvilleguru
Member since Jun 2009
60453 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 7:28 pm to
quote:

It's murder

That's what it is

Murder of a human being

That's one opinion.
Posted by PrivatePublic
Member since Nov 2012
17848 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 7:31 pm to
What's the point? Any link I post arguing for the existence of the soul would likely be from a religious expert, which you would quickly denounce as biased and unscientific.

But I'll give you a good one: how does science explain when a man willingly jumps in front of a car to save a stranger? Natural selection and passing of genetic information doesn't fit very well in such a situation.
Posted by TbirdSpur2010
ALAMO CITY
Member since Dec 2010
134326 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 7:32 pm to
I'm not making any distinction, and yes I think all abortion is fricked up.

Just commenting on the subject of the OP.
Posted by pvilleguru
Member since Jun 2009
60453 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 7:34 pm to
quote:

Any link I post arguing for the existence of the soul would likely be from a religious expert
That doesn't sound like evidence.
Posted by Dawg in Beaumont
Athens
Member since Jan 2012
4495 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 7:36 pm to
I agree with you that there isn't scientific evidence for a human soul.

There also isn't scientific evidence for women's rights. You can't look under a microscope and see irrefutable evidence that we should treat different skin colored people equally. There is no molecular reason for why it's right to treat gay people with decency.

We accept those things because of morality. Plenty of people differ on the abortion issue, but I'm prolife for the same reasons I'm pro women's right, pro gay rights, and against racism.
This post was edited on 3/23/16 at 7:38 pm
Posted by Kentucker
Rabbit Hash, KY
Member since Apr 2013
20055 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 7:59 pm to
quote:

What's the point? Any link I post arguing for the existence of the soul would likely be from a religious expert, which you would quickly denounce as biased and unscientific.


No need to get defensive. tRant is about discussion and sharing of ideas. No judgment takes place here. (Okay, you might want to ignore that last one. )

Denounce? No, but I wouldn't accept it as evidence. I rely upon the scientific method when determining what is reality for me.

I don't demand that others think the way I do, but I would physically fight anyone who tried to coerce me into thinking the way they do.

quote:

But I'll give you a good one: how does science explain when a man willingly jumps in front of a car to save a stranger?


In a word, the scientific explanation is empathy. It's a hallmark of conscienceness.

It's expressed in varying degrees amongst individuals. Most people would avoid danger in helping others but some would, regardless of their religious orientation.

Morality is not based in religion. Neither is it limited to humans. While being far less developed in other animals than it is in humans, conscienceness is certainly expressed by other species.
Posted by Kentucker
Rabbit Hash, KY
Member since Apr 2013
20055 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 8:06 pm to
quote:

There also isn't scientific evidence for women's rights. You can't look under a microscope and see irrefutable evidence that we should treat different skin colored people equally. There is no molecular reasonor for why it's right to treat gay people with decency.


Repeating what I said in a post above, the answer is empathy, the hallmark trait of conscienceness in humans. We can see the world through others' eyes. It's called the Theory of Mind. We recognize others and their rights to live.

quote:

We accept those things because of morality.


Morality is not dependent upon religion. Rather, the reverse is true. Unfortunately, it seems inevitable that one or a few people decide that their morals should be the basis of a particular religion. Examples; John Smith and Mormonism; L. Ron Hubbard and Scientology.
This post was edited on 3/23/16 at 8:09 pm
Posted by Dawg in Beaumont
Athens
Member since Jan 2012
4495 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 8:14 pm to
I agree with you about what empathy is and I agree that morality isn't dependent on religion.

I had two points in mind with what I wrote:1-I was making the case that someone can be non-religious and pro-life, though I acknowledge most pro-life people are religious.

2-Just because something can't be scientifically proven doesn't mean it can't have a legitimate case in moral questions. I think racial equality, gay rights, etc. are good arguments for that.
Posted by Kentucker
Rabbit Hash, KY
Member since Apr 2013
20055 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 8:21 pm to
quote:

Just because something can't be scientifically proven doesn't mean it can't have a legitimate case in moral questions. I think racial equality, gay rights, etc. are good arguments for that.


I'm saying that those things do have a scientific basis. Morality and empathy are directly related.
Posted by TideJoe
Member since Sep 2012
939 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 8:40 pm to
quote:

She may be a fantastic person but she won't ever be able to live on her own


That's not entirely true. My wife has a cousin with DS that won't ever be on her own, but my mom has a cousin in Indiana who is in the 50-55 range with DS and he lives in his own house and rides a Vespa to work (at a local diner, busses tables). I've been in his house and he has it together. His parents have passed but he is still rolling thru life. I don't blame people that don't want to raise a DS child (but please let abortion be the last choice), but they can be functional on their own.
Posted by Old Sarge
Dean of Admissions, LSU
Member since Jan 2012
63942 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 8:53 pm to
I have a soul, but if you can hold a baby in your hands and still not understand that it is wrong to allow people to freely murder them, then perhaps you don't have one.
Posted by Kentucker
Rabbit Hash, KY
Member since Apr 2013
20055 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 9:14 pm to
quote:

I have a soul, but if you can hold a baby in your hands and still not understand that it is wrong to allow people to freely murder them, then perhaps you don't have o


I don't have a soul and neither do you. "Soul" is a religious idea, not a physical reality.

I have held two babies in my hands and I love everything about them. Yes, to kill them would be murder.

The Supreme Court has determined that legal life begins when a fetus is capable of living on its own outside the womb. I agree with that. Ending a pregnancy any time before that stage is not murder.
Posted by Old Sarge
Dean of Admissions, LSU
Member since Jan 2012
63942 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 9:45 pm to
A newborn is not capable of living on its own, a 3 year old will die if left on its own as will a senior citizen with Alzheimer's or that is unable to get out of bed.


By your logic it should not be murder to freely take and end the lives of all of the above.
Posted by pvilleguru
Member since Jun 2009
60453 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 9:50 pm to
quote:

I have a soul, but if you can hold a baby in your hands and still not understand that it is wrong to allow people to freely murder them, then perhaps you don't have one.

I thought we were talking about fetuses.
Posted by Sneaky__Sally
Member since Jul 2015
12364 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 9:50 pm to
Do DS people have a lot of kids. If you murder a person who wasn't going to procreate you didn't do anything but murder someone.
Posted by Kentucker
Rabbit Hash, KY
Member since Apr 2013
20055 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 9:58 pm to
quote:

A newborn is not capable of living on its own, a 3 year old will die if left on its own as will a senior citizen with Alzheimer's or that is unable to get out of bed.


"On its own" is defined as being able to live outside the woman's body, even if artificial support is required. The average age of a fetus that is capable of surviving outside the womb with support is 22 weeks.
Posted by Kentucker
Rabbit Hash, KY
Member since Apr 2013
20055 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 10:01 pm to
quote:

I thought we were talking about fetuses.


Generally speaking, the term fetus refers to in-the-womb and child or baby denotes outside-the-womb. However, there are obviously no hard rules for use of specific terminology.
Posted by Kentucker
Rabbit Hash, KY
Member since Apr 2013
20055 posts
Posted on 3/23/16 at 10:04 pm to
quote:

Do DS people have a lot of kids.


Approximately half of DS females are fertile. If they give birth, nearly one third of their offspring duplicate the defect of the mothers.
Posted by Iron Lion
Romulus
Member since Nov 2014
14425 posts
Posted on 3/24/16 at 1:45 am to
Spartan Law
Posted by Old Sarge
Dean of Admissions, LSU
Member since Jan 2012
63942 posts
Posted on 3/24/16 at 7:45 am to
Oh, look, it's a 21 week old fetus, let's murder it because it can't possibly be human

first pageprev pagePage 3 of 5Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•Twitter