Started By
Message

re: Georgia is the best job in the SEC but can be a nightmare

Posted on 5/7/18 at 8:55 am to
Posted by jimdog
columbus, ga
Member since Dec 2012
6636 posts
Posted on 5/7/18 at 8:55 am to
Of course I am 100% wrong! I just got confused and let the talent scouts who do that stuff for a living muddle my brain. Outside the QB's (and you only need one) count where the players in the draft are generally coming from. Remember we are talking "elite" players. And oh, btw, the state of Texas has 8, actually nine when you throw in OU, universities of significance competing for their players. And Florida has 3 booger bear schools. In-state Georgia competes against air mostly although Tech is a significant presence.

Nick Saban who has some expertise in this venue says it (best job in the country) so I and my eyes tend to make me believe it. He's coached at Michigan St (in the same state and or conference as OSU, Mich, PSU), LSU, and Alabama. And recruited all over the country so he would know. Georgia just had the best EVER recruiting class on paper...EVER is awhile btw.. The crux of which were Georgia players. It's the best by a significant margin.
Posted by Sunbeam
Member since Dec 2016
2612 posts
Posted on 5/7/18 at 9:11 am to
One thing I tend to look at more than recruiting services and stars is who actually becomes NFL players after college is said and done.

There have been a bunch of those over the years, and every year or two some writer beats the horse again.

They fluctuate, but more often than not Louisiana and Mississippi tend to be at the top of per capita NFL players produced.

I've seen some where SC is ahead of Georgia, and vice versa. Offhand I'd say the two states are pretty comparable for that specific measure (NFL players produced per capita).

And just from memory, I think Alabama generally does better than the rest of the Southern states, though you could see one with them ranked fourth or seventh or something.

Anyway all the Southern states do pretty well in that respect, though Louisiana and Mississippi are outliers.

And with the population, of course Georgia is going to produce more players than Mississippi and even Louisiana when you see how many kids from a state sign to play every year.

But interestingly states like Florida and Texas don't usually do as well on a per capita basis compared to some smaller states that are less heralded.

Part of it is if you are a super athlete from Slap Out, Alabama you just do not get people paying attention to you compared to a guy who may not be as good, but plays at St. Thomas Aquineas in Fort Lauderdale.
Posted by TideFaninFl
On the space coast
Member since Oct 2017
6654 posts
Posted on 5/7/18 at 10:04 am to
quote:

Of course I am 100% wrong! I just got confused and let the talent scouts who do that stuff for a living muddle my brain. Outside the QB's (and you only need one) count where the players in the draft are generally coming from. Remember we are talking "elite" players. And oh, btw, the state of Texas has 8, actually nine when you throw in OU, universities of significance competing for their players. And Florida has 3 booger bear schools. In-state Georgia competes against air mostly although Tech is a significant presence.

Nick Saban who has some expertise in this venue says it (best job in the country) so I and my eyes tend to make me believe it. He's coached at Michigan St (in the same state and or conference as OSU, Mich, PSU), LSU, and Alabama. And recruited all over the country so he would know. Georgia just had the best EVER recruiting class on paper...EVER is awhile btw.. The crux of which were Georgia players. It's the best by a significant margin.


OK, let us say you are 100% correct, then Georgia is the most snake-bitten, under achieving program in the history of the world. All that talent on the UGA team, wasted, and you are defending them? Coach Saban is famous for two things, winning titles, and giving his completion a sense of superiority (to then yank the rug out from under them)....

Until UGA actually proves they are worthy, then you might want to pull back just a tad......and no, going to three NC games all-time is not proving you are worthy.....



Posted by DawgsLife
Member since Jun 2013
59020 posts
Posted on 5/7/18 at 11:34 am to
quote:

Of course I am 100% wrong! I just got confused and let the talent scouts who do that stuff for a living muddle my brain.

Dude. I just gave you a link giving you the statistics on exactly how many of those players are in each state. Those ratings were given by the scouts. So, yes. You were 100% wrong. Show me a link where all the "talent scouts" say Georgia has more than any other state in the nation.
quote:

Remember we are talking "elite" players.
You didn't even look at the link I provided, did you?
The title of the article is :All 50 states, ranked by their percentage of the country's elite college football recruits

quote:

In-state Georgia competes against air mostly although Tech is a significant presence.

Because Auburn, Alabama, Clemson, Florida, FSU, USC, Tennessee do not recruit in Georgia do they?

Come on dude. Give it up. You have been proven wrong on just about every single point you've made. You have given your opinion and when I showed you actual stats you want to pretend you didn't see it? (I guess that is what you are pretending)
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter