Way to miss the point entirely. Also, I never said or implied that Eli was better. I just said he seems to have a certain emotional drive that Peyton lacks.

If you wanna put up huge stats and pretty numbers and look good all season, give me Peyton over any quarterback ever.

If you want to win one game - the Super Bowl, and it comes down to the "will to win" as much as it does the X's and O's, then give me Brady, Montana, Favre, Eli, Young, Bradshaw, Aikman, Elway... all long before Peyton.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by Roger Klarvin

DFW

Member since Nov 2012

46572 posts

Posted on 2/3/14 at 11:52 am to genro

quote:
If you want to win one game - the Super Bowl, and it comes down to the "will to win" as much as it does the X's and O's, then give me Brady, Montana, Favre, Eli, Young, Bradshaw, Aikman, Elway... all long before Peyton.

See, stuff like this is just emotional nonsense.

Terry Bradshaw has more career postseason INTs than TDs and personally lost THREE playoff games with turnovers in the final minute. Brett Favre has the most postseason losses as the Vegas favorite in history. Elway lost THREE Superbowls and played horribly in all three. Montana, Brady and Aikman? Sure, but all three played on better teams ith better coaching than Peyton ever will.

The funny thing is that one of the guys you chose, Steve Young, had a worse postseason reputation than Manning. So even by your own flawed metric, you wouldn't pick him over Peyton.

1 ...

Report Post

SEC Rant - Replies to Post

Return To Board

Page 1

Return To Board