Started By
Message
re: Playoffs will have its own poll system ...
Posted on 4/23/13 at 3:52 pm to FlukerFlakes
Posted on 4/23/13 at 3:52 pm to FlukerFlakes
quote:
The only change that should have been undertaken was:
1.) take the top 4 ranked teams in the BCS
2.) no conditions; the top 4 ranked teams
3.) 1v4; 2v3
4.) then national title game
Bingo. All the complaints people have about the BCS and specifically the problems with the 03, 04 and 11 seasons would be solved by just reaching down and picking up the next 2 teams in the rankings.
Posted on 4/23/13 at 5:03 pm to Cockopotamus
I'm afraid not. 2004 had 5 undefeated teams. You had your 3 BCS teams and then Utah and Boise, on top of 1-loss Cal and Texas both ahead of them. 2009 had Alabama, Texas, Cincinnati, Boise State and TCU, plus 1-loss Florida.
Furthermore that wouldn't be close to sufficient to handle bullshite like 07 and 08, where the top ten teams had some form of argument that wasn't completely outrageous.
Four would also have been suboptimal in years like 2002 (where you had undefeated Miami and Ohio State; 2 > 4 there).
I recommend a six-team playoff where the top 2 seeds get first-round byes. It covers the awkward 5-team scenarios which were surprisingly common, it's better than 4-teams for 2-team scenarios (since the undefeated teams get rewarded with a bye while the other four less worthy teams have to fight it out to prove their worth), and it does a better job (although imperfect) of handling the crazy years like 07 and 08.
Furthermore that wouldn't be close to sufficient to handle bullshite like 07 and 08, where the top ten teams had some form of argument that wasn't completely outrageous.
Four would also have been suboptimal in years like 2002 (where you had undefeated Miami and Ohio State; 2 > 4 there).
I recommend a six-team playoff where the top 2 seeds get first-round byes. It covers the awkward 5-team scenarios which were surprisingly common, it's better than 4-teams for 2-team scenarios (since the undefeated teams get rewarded with a bye while the other four less worthy teams have to fight it out to prove their worth), and it does a better job (although imperfect) of handling the crazy years like 07 and 08.
Popular
Back to top
![logo](https://images.tigerdroppings.com/images/layout/SR_Icon.jpg)