Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

Chambliss - NCAA Enforcement Powers

Posted on 3/5/26 at 3:51 pm
Posted by Lurky Guy
Member since Feb 2026
2 posts
Posted on 3/5/26 at 3:51 pm
Hello board! As my name implies, I’m a classic long time lurker first time poster. Exciting times…

All these court cases, along with portal madness (people can leave anytime, just unenroll then reenroll) is seemingly revealing the NCAAs inability to enforce its rules.

I’ve been thinking about this and was hoping someone may have a better understanding, or know why this doesn’t work.

To my understanding, the NCAA was formed by the universities to serve as the ruling body of its member institutions (the universities). So basically, the universities willfully instituted their own governing body.

From the perspective of the NCAA governing “students,” their power is clearly extremely limited (as it should be), hence the students can and will do anything they want.

Why does the NCAA not use its power as intended, govern the universities?
If a university allows a student athlete to compete when ruled ineligible by the ncaa, it is the university that is punished (post season ban, etc), enforced by all of the other universities on themselves.

Along the same thought, if a university has an athlete transfer to their school outside of the portal window, the university would not be allowed them to play, lest they face penalties. Same with tampering etc.

TLDR;
The member institutions of the NCAA seem hellbent on destroying the enforcement of the rules that these same institutions formed the NCAA to enforce - the universities have the power to correct this, and should, by abiding by the rules they vote on together.

Thoughts?

Posted by Quicksilver
Poker Room
Member since Jan 2013
12804 posts
Posted on 3/5/26 at 3:55 pm to
NCAA rules have to follow constitutional law even if university members agree to join the NCAA when they have one that's found to be unconstitutional.
Posted by Murph4HOF
A-T-L-A-N-T-A (that's where I stay)
Member since Sep 2019
18076 posts
Posted on 3/5/26 at 3:56 pm to
quote:

Thoughts?
The NCAA is incredibly inconsistent and it was just a matter of time before someone with a legitimate complaint about not getting another year of eligibility found a friendly court to bring suit. The way the NCAA is incorporated opens the door for state courts to block NCAA rulings.

Tennessee's AD has the right approach to fix all of this, although it would come with a lot of heartburn: collective bargaining for the athletes with clear rules about eligibility.
Posted by OleVaught14
Member since Jun 2019
11093 posts
Posted on 3/5/26 at 3:58 pm to
quote:

collective bargaining for the athletes with clear rules about eligibility.


Until there is a collective bargaining agreement, it will be impossible to get everyone in-line following the same set of rules.
Posted by Lurky Guy
Member since Feb 2026
2 posts
Posted on 3/5/26 at 4:04 pm to
Ignorantly asking - what is unconstitutional about deciding eligibility for a private organization?

From my perspective, there are all kinds of organizations that are allowed to “discriminate” and decide who is allowed to join or not? Of course not based on protected classifications like race.
Posted by theRealJesseD
Member since Nov 2021
4681 posts
Posted on 3/5/26 at 4:08 pm to
quote:

I’m a classic long time lurker first time poster. Exciting times…


first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter