Updated Heisman Trophy Odds - Sept. 18, 2025

Online Sportsbook BetOnline released updated 2025 Heisman Trophy Odds this week, with LSU quarterback Garrett Nussmeier at 14/1.

Through three games this season, Nussmeier has passed for 689 yards with three touchdowns and two interceptions. His QB rating is 75.3, which ranks 37th nationally.

Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer is the current favorite at 15/2.

2025 Heisman Odds:
John Mateer 15/2 (+750)
Carson Beck 8/1
Dante Moore 10/1
Gunner Stockton 12/1
Garrett Nussmeier 14/1
Jeremiah Smith 16/1
Julian Sayin 16/1
Marcel Reed 16/1
Devon Dampier 18/1
Ty Simpson 20/1
Jackson Arnold 22/1
Jayden Maiava 22/1
Arch Manning 25/1
Drew Allar 25/1
Fernando Mendoza 25/1
Thomas Castellanos 25/1
Beau Pribula 28/1
Behren Morton 33/1
Dylan Raiola 40/1
Haynes King 40/1
Sawyer Robertson 40/1
Bryce Underwood 50/1
Diego Pavia 50/1
Josh Hoover 50/1
Sam Leavitt 50/1
Taylor Green 50/1
Kevin Jennings 60/1
CJ Carr 66/1
Demond Williams Jr 66/1
Jake Retzlaff 66/1
Jalon Daniels 66/1
Jeremiyah Love 66/1
LaNorris Sellers 66/1
Cade Klubnik 75/1
Miller Moss 75/1
Austin Simmons 100/1
Byrum Brown 100/1
DJ Lagway 100/1
Rocco Becht 100/1
Ryan Williams 100/1
Eli Holstein 150/1