Favorite team:Alabama 
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:10
Registered on:7/20/2013
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message

re: Any chance Bama folds this year?

Posted by hwqqll on 7/25/15 at 10:30 pm
quote:

That's a tall task for any team replacing their starting QB, WR, and RB.


This is the type of thing that always grinds my gears. Having stars at offensive skill positions is literally the worst predictor of college football success possible. They're the easiest positions for freshmen to pick up and learn; look at Mark Ingram, Julio Jones, Amari Cooper, and TJ Yeldon for Alabama over the past few years, or Nick Chubb, Todd Gurley, Marcus Lattimore, or even Fournette. QB's a little trickier; bad QBs can sink a team (Florida 2010-14, Texas 2010-14, Auburn 2012), but depending on the offensive system, an average QB often produces better team results than a star QB. Of the last 10 SEC champions, 7 had first-year starters at QB.

If you say that our retooled secondary or offensive line might come up short this year, you have a point. But saying that replacing offensive skill players would lose us those games isn't very astute.
This has got to be a joke. Yeldon lost 4 fumbles in 2013. So did Tre Mason. Jeremy Hill is an outlier with 1 fumble lost, but other SEC running backs are comparable; Alex Collins for Arkansas and Mike Davis for South Carolina lost 3. We were spoiled with Trent and Mark, who never fumbled. I wish TJ fumbled less, but it's not bad enough for me to criticize him about it. Anyone who thinks that a 6 YPC back with 2 1,000 yard seasons after 2 years should be benched is an idiot who I have no respect for, because they do not respect the people who put on the jersey every Saturday for our university.
The TJ Yeldon lack of appreciation is borderline absurd. He rushed for 149 yards against A&M, 121 against Ole Miss, 133 against LSU, and 141 against Auburn. He broke 120 yards in 6 of 8 SEC games. His 6.0 ypc is better than Trent Richardson in 2011 (5.8) and comparable to Ingram in 09 (6.1).
There are plenty of Alabama players from the mid-2000s who have had solid NFL careers for a long time, including Charlie Peprah, Roman Harper, Mark Anderson, and Wallace Gilberry. Because of this, I think we'd have a lot of depth on defense. My roster would look something like this:


QB: McCarron
RB: Lacy, Richardson, Alexander, Yeldon, Ingram
WR: Julio Jones, Amari Cooper, Tyrone Prothro
TE: Michael Williams, OJ Howard
LT: Andre Smith, Cyrus Kouandjio, James Carpenter
LG: Chance Warmack
C: Antoine Caldwell
RG: Barrett Jones
RT: DJ Fluker, Mike Johnson

DE: Marcel Dareus, Jesse Williams, Mark Anderson, Wallace Gilberry,
DT: Terrence Cody, Josh Chapman
LB: Courtney Upshaw, DeMeco Ryans, Dont'a Hightower, CJ Mosley, Rolando McClain, Nico Johnson
CB: Dee Milliner, Dre Kirkpatrick, Javier Arenas
S: Mark Barron, Charlie Peprah, Roman Harper, HaHa Clinton-Dix, Landon Collins, Rashad Johnson

24 guys are 1st-team All-Americans or 1st round draft picks (assuming HaHa and CyKo go in the first round this year)
I'm a huge fan of Nuss. He's the best OC that I can ever remember us having, and I think the switch flipped for him after last year's A&M game. We lost that game because A) his bad playcalling that allowed A&M to get up 20-0 and B) his refusal to run the ball in the 2nd half. However, he's learned his lessons since that game. We won Georgia, TAMU this year, and LSU this year because of his insistence on running the ball in the 2nd half. He also learned something from the start of last year's TAMU game. When we got down by 14 this year, he threw out the running gameplan and let AJ air it out so we could catch back up, then went to the run. Without Nussmeier we wouldn't have beaten A&M this year.
South Carolina's 35-7 win over Georgia was a lot more impressive than Texas A&M's 29-24 win over Alabama. As anyone who watched the SEC championship last year can attest, Alabama and Georgia were pretty equal. A&M played Florida a lot closer, but the SC game against Florida was such an aberration that it's hard to compare. How many times does a team score 44 points while racking up 180 yards of total offense? SC also beat a good Clemson team, while A&M is too busy whining about Texas to preserve their own historic in-state rivalry.

Also, we're a better road team than home team. Aggie fans, beating us at Kyle Field would be a bigger accomplishment than beating us in Bryant-Denny.

re: Ten Best SEC Teams since 2000

Posted by hwqqll on 8/5/13 at 9:30 pm
1. Alabama 2011
2. LSU 2011

After this, I'm not really sure.
At first I didn't want to play A&M without Manziel, since we wouldn't be beating them at full strength. But now that I think about it a little more, A&M losing because of Manziel not playing just further underscores the superiority of the entire philosophy of our football program. Alabama would never be caught in a position where losing one player wrecked an entire season, and we would never let a player's fame get out of hand like Manziel's has.

re: Getting rid of divisions?

Posted by hwqqll on 7/22/13 at 6:52 pm
Head to head would be the first tiebreaker. I haven't thought through how it would work after that.

Getting rid of divisions?

Posted by hwqqll on 7/22/13 at 5:45 pm
I saw an idea the other day about adopting a pod-style schedule like the Big Sky has. In this schedule, there would be no divisions. Each team would have 2 permanent rivals and cycle through the rest of the conference in 4 years, playing every other team either 2 or 3 times. Would y'all like or dislike this? I would easily prefer this to playing teams from the east only once every six years.