Started By
Message

Roster management- by the numbers year comparison

Posted on 9/20/20 at 9:00 am
Posted by meansonny
ATL
Member since Sep 2012
25481 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 9:00 am
Since the removal of Richt, I've paid close attention to the roster management by Kirby. Both in talent acquisition and the spread by position and class.

We cannot let 2020 slip by without a big year. I dont expect much dropoff in 2021. But this clearly is the most talented roster that Smart has fielded and it isnt close. The difference this season versus 2018 and 2019 is the amount of talent in the upper-classmen. If someone shares a good depth chart for 2017, I'd be happy to stretch the data back another year.

The biggest glaring difference is upper class starters.
2020 = 20 out of 26 (including sam, nickel, dime, p, and pk). This is 21 if JT Daniels is the starter.

2019 = 9

2018 = 14.

Upperclass second stringers
2020 = 10 (11 if JT Daniels is included)
2019 = 5
2018 = 12

I haven't included 2017 yet. But I remember all of those seniors returning. Upper class leadership is underappreciated by fans in terms of expectations.

The difference for the 2020 season? All of those 2017 and 2018 recruits are growing up. Next season will be led by the 2017 returners and those great 2018 and 2019 classes. The talent isnt going away, but we are going to have to figure a lot of things out in the secondary.
This post was edited on 9/20/20 at 10:03 am
Posted by meansonny
ATL
Member since Sep 2012
25481 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 9:00 am to
Recruiting average for starters
2020 = .9309
2019 = .9068
2018 = .92069

Recruiting average for 2nd string.
2020 = .9455
2019 = .93468
2018 = .9325

The second string will be inflated a little because I dont have the P and PK on there. But it is also indicative of the quality of sophomore/freshmen recruits.
This post was edited on 9/20/20 at 9:08 am
Posted by meansonny
ATL
Member since Sep 2012
25481 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 9:00 am to
2020 Starting Roster by composite score
5 Stars
Zamir White 2018 RB 0.9957
Jamaree Salyer 2018 LT 0.9956
Tyson Campbell 2018 CB 0.9944
JT Daniels 2018 QB 0.9912
Nakobe Dean 2019 ILB 0.9908
George Pickens 2019 X Receiver 0.988
Richard Lecounte 2017 SS 0.9876

High 4 Stars (.9400+)
Tyrique Stevenson 2019 Dime 0.9831
Lewis Cine 2019 FS 0.9765
Trey Hill 2018 C 0.9692
Ben Cleveland 2016 RG 0.9565
Kearis Jackson 2018 Y Receiver 0.9451

Low 4 stars (<.9400)
Azeez Ojulari 2018 Jack 0.9391
Mark Webb 2017 Nickel/Dime 0.9387
Malik Herring 2017 DE 0.9345
Jermaine Johnson 2017 Sam 0.9303
Devonte Wyatt 2018 DT 0.9067
D'Wan Mathis 2019 QB 0.8992
Monty Rice 2017 ILB 0.8906

3 Stars
Owen Condon 2018 RT 0.883
Jordan Davis 2018 NT 0.8858
Justin Shaffer 2017 LG 0.8828
Tre' McKitty 2017 TE 0.89
Eric Stokes 2017 CB 0.8578
Matt Landers 2017 Z Receiver 0.857
Jake Camarda 2018 P 0.8393
Jared Zirkel 2020 PK 0.8263



Second String
5 Stars
Nolan Smith 2019 Jack 0.9994
Demetris Robertson 2017 Y Receiver 0.9905
Travon Walker 2019 DE 0.9901
Darnell Washington 2020 TE 0.9893

High 4 Stars (.9400+)
Quay Walker 2018 ILB 0.983
James Cook 2018 RB 0.9786
Marcus Rosemy-Jacksaint 2020 X Receiver 0.9734
Julian Rochester 2016 DT 0.9651
Channing Tindall 2018 ILB 0.9526

Low 4 Stars (<.9400)
Walter Grant 2017 Sam 0.9217
Xavier Truss 2019 LT 0.9158
Warren McClendon 2019 RT 0.9131
DJ Daniel 2017 CB 0.9108
Warren Ericson 2018 LG 0.907
Christopher Smith 2018 FS 0.8991

3 Stars
Ameer Speed 2017 CB 0.8873


This post was edited on 9/20/20 at 9:37 am
Posted by meansonny
ATL
Member since Sep 2012
25481 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 9:00 am to
2019 Starting Roster by composite

5 Stars
Demetris Robertson 2017 Y Receiver 0.9905
Isaiah Wilson 2017 RT 0.9904
Richard Lecounte 2017 SS 0.9876

High 4 Stars (.9400+)
D'Andre Swift 2017 RB 0.9838
Jake Fromm 2017 QB 0.9794
Andrew Thomas 2017 LT 0.9791
Trey Hill 2018 C 0.9692
Ben Cleveland 2016 RG 0.9565

Low 4 stars (<.9400)
Azeez Ojulari 2018 Jack 0.9391
Mark Webb 2017 Nickel/Dime 0.9387
Malik Herring 2017 DE 0.9345
Walter Grant 2017 Sam 0.9217
DJ Daniel 2017 CB 0.9108
Divaad Wilson 2018 Dime 0.9106
Tyler Clark 2016 DT 0.9066
Monty Rice 2017 ILB 0.8906

3 Stars
Lawrence Cager 2015 X Receiver 0.8895
Jordan Davis 2018 NT 0.8858
Tyler Simmons 2016 Z Receiver 0.8822
Eric Stokes 2017 CB 0.8578
Solomon Kindley 2016 LG 0.8408
Jake Camarda 2018 P 0.8393
Rodrigo Blankenship 2015 PK 0.8093
Tae Crowder 2015 ILB 0.8072
JR Reed 2014 FS 0.7979
Eli Wolf 2015 TE 0.7778


2nd string
5 Stars
Jamaree Salyer 2018 C 0.9956
Tyson Campbell 2018 CB 0.9944
Nakobe Dean 2019 ILB 0.9908
George Pickens 2019 X Receiver 0.988
Cade Mays 2018 LT/LG/C/RG/RT 0.9869

High 4 Stars (.9400+)
Dominic Blaylock 2019 Z Receiver 0.9831
Tyrique Stevenson 2019 nickel 0.9831
Quay Walker 2018 ILB 0.983
Otis Reese 2018 SS 0.9575
Kearis Jackson 2018 Y Receiver 0.9451
Scott Woerner 2016 TE 0.9386

High 4 stars (<.9400)
Jermaine Johnson 2017 Sam/Jack 0.9303
Michael Barnett 2015 NT 0.9091
Devonte Wyatt 2018 DT 0.9067
Christopher Smith 2018 FS 0.8991

3 Stars
Ameer Speed 2017 CB 0.8873
David Marshall 2016 DE 0.8762
Tyreque Mcghee 2016 Dime 0.8594
Brian Herrien 2016 RB 0.8489
Stetson Bennett 2017 QB 0.8304


This post was edited on 9/20/20 at 10:16 am
Posted by meansonny
ATL
Member since Sep 2012
25481 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 9:17 am to
2018 Starters by composite

5 Stars
Isaiah Wilson 2017 LT 0.9904
Isaac Nauta 2016 TE 0.9903
Mecole Hardman 2016 x receiver 0.9902
Richard Lecounte 2017 SS 0.9876

High 4 Stars
Terry Godwin 2015 Y Receiver 0.9872
D'Andre Swift 2017 RB 0.9838
Jake Fromm 2017 QB 0.9794
Andrew Thomas 2017 OT 0.9791
Jonathan Ledbetter 2015 DE 0.967
Ben Cleveland 2016 RG 0.9528
Jeremiah Holloman 2017 x receiver 0.9431
D'Andre Walker 2015 Jack 0.9427

Low 4 Stars (<.9400)
Mark Webb 2017 dime 0.9387
Lamont Gaillard 2014 C 0.9367
Walter Grant 2017 Sam 0.9217
Tyler Clark 2016 DT 0.9066
Javon Wims 2016 x receiver 0.9025
Monty Rice 2017 ILB 0.8906

3 Stars
Jordan Davis 2018 NT 0.8858
Tyrique McGhee 2016 nickel 0.8594
Deandre Baker 2015 CB 0.8594
Eric Stokes 2017 CB 0.8578
Solomon Kindley 2016 LG 0.8408
Jake Camarda 2018 P 0.8393
Tae Crowder 2015 ILB 0.8072
JR Reed 2014 SS 0.7979


Second String

5 Stars
Justin Fields 2018 QB 0.9998
Tyson Campbell 2018 CB 0.9944
Demetris Robertson 2017 Y Receiver 0.9905
Adam Anderson 2018 Sam 0.9889
Cade Mays 2018 RG 0.9869

High 4 Stars
Deangelo Gibbs 2017 FS 0.977
Trey Hill 2018 C 0.9692
Julian Rochester 2016 NT 0.9648
Otis Reese 2018 OLB 0.9575
Natrez Patrick 2015 ILB 0.9566
Charlie Woerner 2016 TE 0.9369

Low 4 Stars (<.9400)
Tray Bishop 2017 CB 0.9346
Malik Herring 2017 DE 0.9345
Elijah Holyfield 2016 RB 0.9266
Michael Barnett 2015 SDE 0.9049
Riley Ridley 2016 Y Receiver 0.9036
Kendall Baker 2014 LT 0.8997

3 Stars
Tyler Simmons 2016 WR 0.8822
David Marshall 2016 DT 0.8712
Juwan Taylor 2015 ILB 0.8574
DaQuan Hawkins-Muckle 2015 DT 0.8569
Marshall Long 2016 P 0.8217
This post was edited on 9/20/20 at 10:16 am
Posted by meansonny
ATL
Member since Sep 2012
25481 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 10:42 am to
The biggest things that jump out at me for 2020 to 2019:
We are going from 8 starters over .9400 in the composite up to 12 (7 of those are 5 stars).

The second thing that jumps out at me for 2020 to 2019:
The quality of our 2nd string.
We are replacing Herrien with Cook/Milton.

We are replacing Stetson Bennett with Mathis/Daniels/Beck

We are going from five 3 stars in the second string to one.

Posted by Peter Buck
Member since Sep 2012
12412 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 1:19 pm to
I think Richt was loyal to a fault. Smart takes advantage of 1 year scholarships and recruits better on the front end.
Posted by Porter Osborne Jr
Member since Sep 2012
39955 posts
Posted on 9/20/20 at 1:36 pm to
Thanks for the hard work on this. Lots to take in and digest.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter