re: Meltdown Week 11

quote:

---

The fact that the committee was so wrong should prove how useless and incorrect they are. They're wrong almost every single week. The committee's vote is basically just musical chairs and whoever is in the right seat on the last week gets into the playoffs. What a stupid system.

---

And what system is right every single week? The AP poll? Coaches poll? BCS standings? The CFP rankings are a reflection of the games played up to that point... they're not predictive... they're reactive. If you want a predictive ranking, use the S&P+... in which case, your top 4 is:

Ohio State
Alabama
Wisconsin
Washington

That's right... TWO 2 loss teams. #5 on the bubble? UCF... Then Auburn followed by Georgia (functionally a tie, as the score differential is 16.2 for both).

Generally speaking, by the time the season plays out, the CFP rankings have been at least "good" if not perfect.