re: Alabama QB Mac Jones has orchestrated arguably the best passing attack in CFB history

quote:

---

No answer from SOG. Again what is the definition of a tight window ? Does it change from year to year ? Never seen it as an official NCAA Category.

---

Oh, ok, so we're at the "Puppets tells you what he sees and if you or people who grade film disagree they are dumb".

quote:

---

“Tight” throws are defined by a defender being within an arm’s length of the receiver, or in the right spot in a passing window so as to discourage the throw.

---

PFF - Mac is the best tight-window thrower in football

Puppets - Mac never throws into tight windows



I dunno Jim

quote:

---

But nobody seems to know the answer.

---

Look up.

I’d like to see someone put together a top ten plays by both Jones and Burrow video. Hell I’d like to see it done for a lot of player comparisons.

My guess is Jones would all be laser accurate passes and Burrow’s would be more scrambling type stuff.

Is this my gateway into becoming a YouTube star

quote:

---

I’d like to see someone put together a top ten plays by both Jones and Burrow video. Hell I’d like to see it done for a lot of player comparisons.

My guess is Jones would all be laser accurate passes and Burrow’s would be more scrambling type stuff.

Is this my gateway into becoming a YouTube star

---

Mac's would be traditional QB stuff, mostly deep throws into tight windows.

Joe's would be a fvckin smorgasbord of badassery - mostly the same throws but after maneuvering the pocket, sliding off a LB and falling out of bounds, ending with him calmly smoking a Camel unfiltered and winking.

quote:

---

What the frick?

---

But do screen passes count, because that could explain the whole thing Saint.

By this metric. There are other metrics that would favor LSU’s passing game last year like yards per game and tds per game.

Mac Jones is beyond solid and he’s looked far better and more competent than Tua. Really impressive season.

While you're on hold, please explain why you went silent after your hire and still haven't explained how you were so off.

No SOG, just trying to narrow down the criteria. You throw out a stat with a percentage attacked to it , but can not answer the criteria around it. Is that something you statistically accepted with any numbers or just the ones you like?

quote:

---

You throw out a stat with a percentage attacked to it , but can not answer the criteria around it. Is that something you statistically accepted with any numbers or just the ones you like?

---

We literally defined it man - I'm confused what else you want to read?

If there is a defender within arm's reach of the ball then it's a tight window - yes, that would apply to a screen pass. If you are throwing that soft screen pass into that tight a window it should probably automatically be marked as a bad throw, though.