Started By
Message

re: Alright, season or no?

Posted on 6/29/20 at 10:38 am to
Posted by ATLabama
Member since Jan 2013
1602 posts
Posted on 6/29/20 at 10:38 am to
There is a massive difference between wanting a season, and rationaly believing you are going to have one.

Do we want a season? Of course.

Are we going to have one, at least, the way we've always had one? No - and it's a fool's errand to try to conceptualize an argument otherwise.

Here are the major obstacles you've got to overcome -

(1) Ensuring students are on campus in some capacity this fall. Why? Because under the guise of "amateurism" the NCAA and it's member schools can't profit the way they normally can without school going on, and other students - not just athletes, attending class

(2) 50 states, 50 cases, 50 governors. Thanks to the powers of the 10th amendment and the silence of the federal government up to this point, each state still has the right to mandate what regulations to put in place. Here in Georgia, our fair governor doesn't give a DAMN about COVID-19. Our neighbors to the south, Florida, are experiencing an unbelievable spike in cases. How can you competitively maintain a schedule where Sanford Stadium has ~50% capacity (it won't be 100%, don't care what their e-mail said) versus 0%? Moreover - how about taking 250 university students and personnel to Dallas (major COVID hotbed) to play another 250 university personnel from Los Angeles? Say you get that done - there is still no way you'll have fans, virtually all from outside the state coming in for the game.

(3) Virtually no college has the financial wherewithal to withstand a the legal liability associated with hosting games with more than 20% capacity. COVID-19 is the most publicized pandemic in human history - the information overload from the CDC alone is enough support to take any class-action suit to court and hold a death-blow judgment against any University that decides to host large crowds. "Assumption of risk" will not be a defense, as the argument for gross negligence would be almost indefensible at this juncture.

NFL owners are a totally different hemisphere of wealth and power, and that is why they can take the risk. This isn't a 1-1 situation between college and pro.

If there will be college football this season, it won't have very many fans, if any at all. For schools not like Alabama (Arkansas, Mizzou, Maryland, Indiana, Arizona, etc...), the incentive plainly isn't there to go forward with a full slate. The incentive for schools outside the P5 is plain, zero.

My preference? Punt until the spring.

College football is nothing without its atmosphere. Any return of fans we could have next March would greatly enhance the sport we love. College football in a sterile environment is just not going to be a good product. Heck, Alabama's margin of victory last year was 25.8 - so we know the games themselves (Ok, 2-3) aren't terribly exciting.

We like college football for so many different reasons that is not the game on the field - almost moreso. It's why we still have people attend Alabama-Charleston Southern. It's not the game, it's the surroundings. The quicker we get to that, the better.
This post was edited on 6/29/20 at 10:39 am
Posted by tider04
North Carolina
Member since Oct 2007
5606 posts
Posted on 6/29/20 at 11:35 am to
Waiting until next March poses a whole host of new issues to wade through. Who's to say this pandemic is any better by March? All indications I've seen is that this thing is here to stay for the foreseeable future. A vaccine is not going to be a golden ticket out, unfortunately even if/when we get one.

If we start in March, we pretty much lose all of our Junior and Senior players who will be drafted before the 1st game. Say goodbye to Smitty, Waddle, Najee, Leatherwood, Moses, Surtain, etc, etc. They'll never play a snap of the season. How would the NFL handle the draft? Combines while the CFB season is still going? Are we going to expect football players to play two seasons in one calendar year...one in March and one in September? That won't happen.

I'm not saying I have all the answers, I'm just not sure a spring season is the best we can do. I think a modified season this fall (conference schedule only plus playoff) is doable even if it's without fans. We all need an escape from the hell 2020 has been, and sports is such an escape for millions of people. Plus not having a season this fall would absolutely devastate entire athletic departments and universities. I don't think people realize how many schools rely on football to really fund the whole deal. It would be catastrophic. I say we play a reduced season, still crown a champion and either do it with no fans or a very reduced capacity. Seems the best of all the not so great options to me.
This post was edited on 6/29/20 at 11:41 am
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter