re: Would you fire Coach Jim McElwain?

We've been terrible. The offense is made up of all his recruits except for Sharpe and Goolsby and Lewis. The east is utter garbage. You want to see the difference in how to run a program?

quote:

---

There has been no significant improvement in offense, and the defense has regressed. He's signed 39 3*s regardless. We're #91 in total offense in Mac's 2nd year with the easiest SOS in the SEC! Does Harbaugh 2015 class not count? The one that finished below us. He's 19-3, 4-1 vs the top 25, has top 10 classes and is destroying his competition. He's taken a team that was 5-7 the year before he got there and has them rolling on and off the field. What's Mac excuse? Harbaugh destroyed UF with a grad transfer QB. The difference is one can manage and coach a team and the other cannot. 

Michigan 2014 with Nuss 
#115 in total offense and #111 in ppg 

2015 

#50 scoring offense #69 in total offense 

2016 

#3 scoring offense #20 in total offense. 


UF: 

2016: 
#76 scoring offense #91 in total offense. 

2015: 

#100 in ppg #112 in total offense 

2014: 

#56 scoring offense, #96 in total offense 

Harbaugh started with just as big of a mess than Mac and is killing it and his team has improved greatly in recruiting and play every year 
LINK 

Per 247 Recruiting: 

2015: 37th had 6 commits including a K and legacy before JH arrived. 16Th in average * ranking 


2016: 6th overall 2nd B10 9th in avg * ranking 

2017: 10th 2nd B10 9th in avg* ranking 


UF 

2015: 21st 10th in SEC 20th in avg * ranking 

2016: 12th 6th in SEC 16th in avg * ranking 

2017: 17th 8th in SEC 13th in avg * ranking 

This post was edited on 11/7 at 5:55 am

---

Our program will be in worse shape when Mac is fired next year midseason. All you Bama fans who said he was a HR hire can gfy. Another saban tree failure