re: USCe losing to the Citadel cost them Tom Herman

well my rationale behind that statement is this. We as fan's judge our coaches by wins and losses. Yes, looking strictly at that doesn't bode well for Muschamp. But what makes up those wins and losses? Your teams ability to score points vs their ability to keep the opposing team from scoring points. Now, for comparison's sake, lets look at McElwain's performance this year. Would the UF fan base say that his performance was a failure? No, he went 10-4 and took the Gators to Atlanta, bravo. However, if you go back and look at the stats ppg vs ppga, McElwain's team this year actually under-performed the team Muschamp fielded 3 out of the 4 years. So saying that the resulting wins vs losses wasn't what was hoped for is true, saying he was an outright failure is a bit harsh.