re: aTm Offers ANOTHER 2017 QB from Hawaii -- Tate Martel Questions Ags' Loyalty

quote:

---

If that's how you want them to approach it then you can say bye bye to lots of 5 star QBs

---

Let's take a look at the last 5 years' worth of 5-star quarterbacks.

2015 (1 for 3)

Blake Barnett - minimal playing time
Josh Rosen - Solid starter for UCLA
Kyler Murray - Not ready for prime time

2014 (0 for 1)

Kyle Allen - Brittle and a fragile ego

2013 (1 for 2)

Max Browne - 143 total yards and 11 total completions in 2 seasons
Christian Hackenberg - Serviceable starter

2012 (1 for 2)

Jameis Winston - Heisman winner, #1 pick
Gunner Kiel - left Notre Dame, average player on an average team

2011 (0 for 2)

Jeff Driskel - failed at Florida, average at La. Tech
Braxton Miller - Was decent, but moved to WR/RB

Out of the 10 5 star QBs between the classes of 2011-2015, only 3 can be considered worth the rating.

Let's then examine those who WEREN'T rated as 5-stars from those classes.

2011: Cody Kessler, Jacoby Brissett, Everett Golson, Cardale Jones, Jacob Coker, Connor Cook, Brett Hundley, Teddy Bridgewater, Johnny Manziel, Marcus Mariota, Dak Prescott

2012: Trevor Knight, Chad Kelly (bad year for QB)

2013: Joshua Dodds, Jeremy Johnson, Jared Goff, Baker Mayfield, J.T. Barrett, Malik Zaire

2014: Brad Kaaya, Patrick Mahomes, Deshaun Watson, Brandon Harris

2015: Jarrett Stidham, Lamar Jackson