re: Bama and 5* Recruits

quote:

---

you are skewing the stat in your favor

---

Just as you are, I actually said lets look at all three stats.

quote:

---

Their selection of school led them to be kicked out

---

Precluded, did not necessarily lead. I stubbed my toe getting out of bed, then I found 5 dollars. Should I always stub my toe in order to find 5 dollars every morning?

quote:

---

How do you know they wouldnt have become a first rounder at another program

---

How do you know they would have?

You are playing these runaround games, I don't think you actually believe it either. Just look at all three stats and you can state whichever one is most important to you. And everyone else can form their own opinions. It seems most people are of the opinion that the truncated data set is a more applicable determination of a coach/programs ability to develop players. If you want to discuss ability to keep players out of off the field trouble, that is a different discussion.