re: Bama and 5* Recruits

quote:

---

Well again, you are discrediting the original premise of the stat, 5 star recruits that sign with the program. When you remove them, you again are skewing the stat. Its pretty simple, did 5 star recruit sign with program? yes or no Did 5 star recruit get drafted first round? yes or no Any variation beyond that it merely skewing the statistic to make the stat look more convincing then it really is ETA. And I dont even really care what it is for bama. but when you add more and more disclaimers it discredits the statement.

---

Ask yourself the question, "what was the intention when looking at these statistics?" Answer: To see how well the schools "coach up" their 5* recruits to help them most advantageously enter the NFL draft.
Now if you don't remove the recruits who were dismissed for unacceptable behavior, career-ending injury or any other situation not contributable to the coaching staff, how can you get an accurate assessment of the quality of the coaching staff?
NYC, you're not this dumb...this narrow-minded and hard headed, maybe, but not this dumb.