re: The Heisman should go to McCarron

quote:

---

Because he is reliable year in year out.

---

I understand what you are saying and how you feel, but if reliability was the only criteria, i would have won the Heisman. No, I didn't come close!

quote:

---

the guy has 2 nattys.

---

Were the Nattys won because of his efforts, or because of all the talent around him? In other words, would Alabama have won the Nattys without McCarron?

quote:

---

And just because Oregon lost 2 games doesn't necessarily mean their QB should be taken off the list imo

---

I agree, here. He should definitely still be in the running. The Heisman is an individual award, not a team award.

Don't misunderstand me...I like McCarron. He ran the offense very well. But I would not call him the best player in the country. I mean, using the Natty argument, you would also have to invite every Alabama player that played on those teams.