Started By
Message

re: Do ya'll realize how stupid we look

Posted on 11/5/13 at 2:02 pm to
Posted by FooManChoo
Member since Dec 2012
41789 posts
Posted on 11/5/13 at 2:02 pm to
Yeah, we did get some luck to get into the picture, but that's how most teams do it every year. It's not often that you get an undefeated team in the SEC. Even Alabama lost to A&M last season and still went on to win it all. Shoot, they lost to LSU the year before during the regular season and still got a rematch in the championship game (unheard of) even though they didn't make it to their conference championship.

Luck is usually what really determines the national championship, because rarely do you see a team dominate every single opponent they play. Often times you see a great team get upset in one game that they should have won that causes them to miss out entirely. Oregon has done that a lot recently, but other teams can say the same thing.

There's a lot that happens during a season that can make or break your hope for a title. Sometimes you can make it by losing one game, but only if you lost to a good team, and only if you lose early enough to rebound in the polls. Timing is important. If you do win all your games, you have to hope your SOS was good enough for the voters and computers to put you in the #1 or #2 slot. In the SEC, you have to wind up conference play by playing the best team (record-wise) from the other division. So, you have to beat a potentially tough team just to make it to the title game against a team that might not have a conference championship (ND comes to mind). It's not easy.

Because I believe so much about winning the national title relies on luck, I don't consider it being complacent when I support CMR for winning so many times and giving our program national attention, a few conference championships, and lots of bowl wins. Do I want a national championship? Hell yes I do! But, I don't think that's on the back of CMR to win for us, necessarily. I don't think bringing in a different coach will necessarily increase our chances of winning one, either, because there is no secret formula. You can do things to increase your chances for victory, but sometimes the ball just doesn't bounce your way and it costs you a chance at the title. I don't think bringing in Kelly or anyone else will do much to improve things.
Posted by Damn Good Dawg
Member since Feb 2011
47325 posts
Posted on 11/5/13 at 2:14 pm to
quote:

Life

quote:

Foo

Well said, gentleman, honestly the best arguments that have been brought in defense of richt in a while. Wish most of his apologists went as detailed as yall. That being said I guess we will have to agree to disagree but both yall had very valid points. It's obviously not a black and white issue and that's what makes it so damn complex.

That being said right now we are talking big picture issues but a lot of my lack of faith in Richt stems from the little things but honestly I am about to get carpal tunnel typing novels with you gents so I'll leave that for another day (IF you really wanna see I am sure in my litany of posts there are a few that are novels about the exact issues I have with Richt and his staff, maybe I'll search for it later tonight, used to have it bookmarked).

Also
quote:

Out of curiosity. If Richt wins the Natty next year, will you STILL be saying he should be fired? Why, or why not?


I said earlier in the thread I am not even calling for him to be fired now. Would I be happy? Yep. But that won't happen. I have to wait for an opportunity that actually warrants his firing, like 2010 when I think he should have been fired. My posts really just reflect my lack in faith in Richt but even I know you don't fire a guy who went to 2 SEC title games and had a ton of injuries to deal with....unless he really shits the bed the rest of the year.

But to answer your question IF Richt won a title then no, I wouldn't want him canned. But who would? Hell, if he'd even just get us to a title game I'd likely lose a good bit of my fervor but that hasn't happened yet.

Honestly there actually is a way I could believe in Richt. He'd have to bring in stud coordinators. It's my opinion that Richt would be an excellent CEO coach like Bowden and if we had a Chad Morris/Gus Malzahn type OC and a Foster/Smart type DC I think things could change. But with Richt and our homegrown staff with a leftover NFL DL coach it's hard to be as optimistic.
This post was edited on 11/5/13 at 2:17 pm
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter