NO!!! Not even close. Reggie Bush redshirted his freshmen year. Justin Vincent was in Bushs class and played his first year. Who was more talented???? BUSH!

quote:
Alabama puts the best players on the field regardless of what year they are currently in, it's whoever gives them the best chance to win. 5 star RBs like Ford are not supposed to redshirt, unless they are way overrated and don't deserve that high of a ranking.

Alabamas upper classman arent as talented as LSU. LSU has had top 5-10 recruiting classes since 02. Thats why LSU redshirts most freshmen and Bama has been playing there freshmen the past 2 years.

This post was edited on 9/24/09 at 3:23 pm

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by bstew3006

318

Member since Dec 2007

12583 posts

Posted on 9/24/09 at 3:25 pm to bstew3006

quote:
5 star RBs like Ford are not supposed to redshirt, unless they are way overrated and don't deserve that high of a ranking.

Thatst the dumbest statement ive ever heard. once again Reggie Bush, maybe you heard of him!

Shawn alexander, 5 star RB, still holds many All TIME PREP football records, was redshirted his freshmen year at Alabama. isnt he one of the best RBs Bama has ever had, and wasnt he the NFL MVP one year??? Just something to think about before you keep making yourself sound like a complete nut job

This argument is stupid as frick. Just bc a player is a 5 star RB doesnt mean they have to play right away. Some play the first year, MOST dont. Mainly bc they go to schools that have recruited 5 star RBs in the past, those RB are still playing, just as talented and have more exp.

This post was edited on 9/24/09 at 3:37 pm

2 ...

Report Post

SEC Rant - Replies to Post

Return To Board

Page 1

Return To Board