re: Annual History of the Playoff Selection Committee Decisions - Final 2022 Update

quote:

---

I love the caveat "equal or worse record".

---

That's just an easier way to say "if you have 2 losses you generally probably aren't making it in over a team with 1 loss"

quote:

---

there have only been 8 year of playoffs that yall have determined this is how it will be every year b/c of the previous 8

---

well, other than the actual decisiosn the committee has made every year of the playoff's existence...what else should we go by? Feelings and emotions? I think looking at their track record is as good a resource as any when trying to put the puzzle together.

quote:

---

Do you think this year is the same as the previous 8?

---

I see no reason to the think the committee will change the way they make selections.

quote:

---

PSU was left out and OSU got in. PSU was the conference champ. I

---

Because PSU had 2 losses...see point #1 up top of this post.

quote:

---

In this thread the guy who has laid out the "precedents" also said he doesn't think UGA gets in if LSU wins out

---

You left out the caveat of there being all other 1-loss P5 champions. We have literally never seen a scenario where an undefeated team has played for and lost their CCG, and still made the playoffs over a P5 chamipon with the same record. Both times a CCG loser has made the playoffs, the next best P5 winner you could replace them with had 2 losses.