Started By
Message
0
Posted on 10/26/23 at 10:47 pm to Crimson77
quote:
7. Oregon (1 quality loss on the road, looked better against bad teams) 8. Bama (1 quality loss at home, 3 quality wins, looked worse against bad teams)
How do you have 3 quality wins below a team with 0 quality wins but looked good against bad teams? Your logic doesn’t compute.
Posted on 10/27/23 at 7:47 am to TideWarrior
quote:
A question was asked which I assumed you were looking for people's opinion not reassurance of Alabama's season and mediocre play because your insecurity has you feeling down.
Maybe next time include in the OP it is a support thread.
Literally said in the OP the objective was to initiate debate about the logic about what the top 10 should be lol
I’m sorry your logic happens to be super easy to punch holes in
This post was edited on 10/27/23 at 7:49 am
Posted on 10/27/23 at 1:30 pm to HighTide_ATL
quote:
Literally said in the OP the objective was to initiate debate about the logic about what the top 10 should be lol
I’m sorry your logic happens to be super easy to punch holes in
Again your opinion is not logic. Logic is usually provided to help support facts not an opinion.
You asked for opinions, and one was provided. Again, we do not have to agree hence the word debate but that does not make one right over the other because you think your opinion is more valuable than someone else.
You seem very sensitive when someone does not agree along with another in this thread. In the end we all support UA and it will be alright for you.
Posted on 10/28/23 at 7:36 am to TideWarrior
quote:
Again your opinion is not logic. Logic is usually provided to help support facts not an opinion.
"Usually." So you admit logic can be used to support one's opinion. Glad we got that out of the way I guess lol
quote:
You asked for opinions, and one was provided. Again, we do not have to agree hence the word debate but that does not make one right over the other because you think your opinion is more valuable than someone else.
You seem very sensitive when someone does not agree along with another in this thread. In the end we all support UA and it will be alright for you.
It's sensitive to debate a topic and point out reasoning I don't agree with?
You realize just because we all can have opinions doesn't mean they're all equally valuable right? Opinions rooted in measurable data typically have more validity than others.
Look you can believe Penn St is better than Bama. I think your reasoning is piss poor and pointed out the holes in it (point of the thread), but you're right, we'll continue to support UA (some of us more than others I suppose) and everything will be ok
Posted on 10/28/23 at 2:23 pm to HighTide_ATL
quote:
It's sensitive to debate a topic and point out reasoning I don't agree with?
You seem to be very sensitive by your post. A good debate should not involve so much emotion on your part but understand for some why this is.
quote:
You realize just because we all can have opinions doesn't mean they're all equally valuable right?Opinions rooted in measurable data typically have more validity than others.
I understand what an opinion is, but you seem to think your opinion has more value. Data can be interpreted many ways and just because it is your interpretation does not add any value.
Based on how you want to measure something I guess now UVA is a world beater because they beat UNC so any team that beats UVA is better than UNC. That does not make it a fact no matter how you try and sell it.
quote:
Bama has a win over Ole Miss, which beat LSU.
What Ole Miss did against LSU how no bearing on how good UA is or will do against LSU next week.
quote:
Look you can believe Penn St is better than Bama.
I have never said that. I said I would have them ranked higher as a 1 loss team because they lost to OSU which I think is a better loss then UA losing to Texas. I believe in my opinion that OSU is a better team than Texas.
quote:
I think your reasoning is piss poor and pointed out the holes in it
You pointed nothing except your opinion that UA is better than PSU which I never disagreed.
quote:
we'll continue to support UA (some of us more than others I suppose) and everything will be ok
And here is where you fail in trying to bring logic into the conversation. Just because I do not drink the Kool-Aid you do I do not support UA? Logic in my mind should not involve bias but you clearly are using it to justify where you think Alabama should be ranked. I have yet to see bias ever being measurable.
I am sure I will get a response from you about something I did not say or how I am not a true fan because I do not agree with you.
This post was edited on 10/28/23 at 3:10 pm
Page 3 of 3
Latest Alabama News
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News