Favorite team:LSU 
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:2384
Registered on:4/24/2012
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
Kelly never lost to anyone as bad as this Arkansas team in 3+ years, and the home games were never in serious doubt in the 4th quarter, but sure.
quote:

I think it’s just the residual of COVID redshirts still hanging around. Next year should regress back to the mean


It’s this, and as they wash out, having a starting 22 that’s too old to be in college is going to start to go away, unless and until the NCAA caves completely on eligibility requirements.

If/when that happens, college football is well and truly cooked.

Even as much as it’s talked about, I don’t think we will have a good understanding of how completely anomalous the last few years have been for a while still.

Covid kids, plus Covid nuking HS development/talent identification, plus unlimited transfers, plus early stage pay for play is an unreal amount of change for the sport.

Nothing that’s happened since since about 2022 can be relied upon as a consistent guide for future success, or roster/program building.
He’s been mentioned by every CFB personality for every major opening all season. His agent is obviously trying to get him a raise and to strip whatever is left of admissions standards/transfer restrictions for football at ND. Nothing more.

I think he would be an incredible hire, but I do not think the obvious push to get his name floated everywhere is related to anything other than negotiations at ND.
The current staff is full of LSU re-treads after all of Kelly’s guys flamed out within 2 years.

Woody is a meddlesome loser, and needs to be shown the door. He’s sabotaged two HCs he didn’t get along with in the same way with the same people. Make sure the new coach is the actual boss and everyone knows it.
It’s not just last Saturday. The RB run game has been successful for a month, we just never run the ball.

Against Scar: 24 RB carries for 138 (5.75 YPC)
Vandy: 19 RB carries for 113 (5.9 YPC)
aTm: 15 RB carries for 97 (6.4 YPC)
He sucks, but you’re not counting at least 2 Ws in @Mizzou 2023 and @Scar 2024. As long as nobody knows it’s a big game at the time, he can win them.
LSU has already completely overhauled the personnel department.

At this point, I am not sure what Kelly even really has authority over. Probably not personnel/roster, and he doesn’t directly oversee either side of the ball. There’s been suggestion he didn’t even really have autonomy on the Baker hire.
If we assume we are going portal for QB and don’t hire the identified QB’s coordinator, we riot.
Kelly thinks he came here to save us, but the fanbase, rightfully, thinks LSU always offered him more than he offered LSU. That’s why he left ND to come here.

He has not communicated anything in a way that reflects that since the alignment talk in his first PC. He “fit” fine when he was hired, but he forgot LSU is the star of this show sometime shortly after he got here. That’s the disconnect.

He’s here to capitalize on the LSU brand and history of success, but he acts and talks like he’s trying to fix a fundamentally broken thing. Maybe it was that screwed up when he showed up, but it’s hard to sell that to a fanbase when they watched a natty 4 years before you were hired. His tone and message just lacks a basic understanding of the expectations and experiences of the fanbase.
Whoever you hire next, they have to first and foremost coach football. I believe the sport has largely outgrown the “CEO” model that was relied upon when BK was hired.

The coach isn’t the top of the org. chart anymore. Gotta be a coach, because a lot of the other stuff that the HC ran just 10 years ago is no longer the preview of the HC.

The biggest hope, and unknown, is that BK set the organization up for his successor to succeed, similar to how Freeman has been able to launch off of the BK foundation at ND.
He doesn’t look or talk like he cares much for the way CFB is run these days. If he wants out of the mitigation obligations to “retire” maybe you can work down the buyout.

I assume the FO buildout has been done to stay around and manage retention of the investment in the roster. So you shouldn’t have to turn too much of that over.

Most of the guys anyone would want to retain on this staff are loyal to LSU more than BK. Is there anyone you’d want to keep around that isn’t an O holdover other than Peoples, and he’s more tied to Baker.

One thing you have to do is get somebody with some players on board. One of the most underrated problems with BK hire is that he brought none of his players. It really exacerbated the roster issue.

I don’t care if Brent Key is a GT alumn. If you can get the OC and some players to ride along, that’s where I’m going. He’s been bleeding high end players to the SEC. I just don’t think the right offer wouldn’t move him regardless of his connection to the school.
It was just as dumb to play him against SELU as it was to play Nuss, and the decisions were probably related.

re: Play calling is terrible

Posted by CrippleCreek on 10/12/25 at 10:13 am to
The scripted stuff is truly awful, and should probably be delegated to somebody other than whoever is doing it currently, but we had 5 60+ yard drives. Moved the ball consistently and in chunks, ran the ball well for the most part, and were balanced.

Feels like a good week to cut Sloan some slack.
Lost by 5 points on the road.

Started the year needing to go 3-2 on the road to make the playoffs, and hold serve at home. 1-1 so far. 2-0 would be better, but acting like the sky is falling is just so insanely dumb.

I think this board is just chock full of fans who didn’t experience ‘03 or ‘07 now, and their only point of reference is 2019. LSU can, and has, won BIG with teams that couldn’t hold 2019’s jock, and that lost games.

There’s a lot more football to enjoy, if you let yourself. I’m hoping the SC crowd is a mirror of that 2012 game. The online crowd was so down on the team after an offensive turd performance at Florida, but inside the stadium, that was one of the most underrated crowds ever.

I think Kelly thought they were going to body bag Ole Miss. The game week rhetoric sounded a lot like FSU in 2023. Obviously wrong, but that would explain the decision not to shut Nuss down against SELA when you combine it with thinking he was improving.

The decision to play against SELA also wasn’t made knowing we were going to OM without Durham. As mad as the telestrstor made everyone about him a couple weeks ago, he’s clearly the best back and would have gotten more than the 2 touches the RBs got in the first half. Without him you can’t hide Nuss against anybody.
Agreed, there was no sound justification for playing Nuss against SELA after BK said he won’t be right till after the bye.

Between the rest for Nuss, making Ole Miss waste a period or two in prep on it, and the possibility of finding something you want to use out of MVB, it just doesn’t make any sense.
Played the whole game without Durham, the whole second half without A Anderson, and Trey Green still clearly limited. They don’t come close to fixing everything, but once you lose those guys, the skill talent is average at best on this team.

Add a clearly injured QB and you’re screwed. The “solution” to the extent there is one, is to get healthy over the bye, and make sure Berry is ready to be a real player on this team splitting the load with Durham. 10+ touches each.

And, while scheme won’t change, BK has to call the game in an analytically sound way. Complimentary football with this defense/offense combo isn’t long field goals and conservative punts. It’s aggression on 4 down territory because the D can back you up. It doesn’t matter how shitty the offense is, taking 4 cracks to get 10 yards is hard to stop. See the last TD drive.

Got to find a way to go 3-0 over the next stretch before the bye, and win one of Alabama/OU. Break it into chunks and it looks more manageable.
All that is true, and there’s an offensive skill talent problem too. Especially once you lose Aaron Anderson.

Yesterday, in year 4, LSU didn’t have a single BK HS recruit contributing on offense until Berry in the 4Q. All those portal guys would be nice final pieces, but none of them are dynamic enough to say this offense actually has a bunch of skill talent, and that is exacerbated by the fact that the offense has no “easy button” stuff.

re: Coaching to win the game.

Posted by CrippleCreek on 9/15/25 at 12:34 pm to
LSU moved the ball fine from the second quarter until the moment Johnson and Nuss gave the ball away on back to back plays.

Everything else was being conservative and playing field position.

If we all agree the team can’t get where it wants to go under and circumstances if Nuss gets hurt, he should never run against Tech. He probably was on a very direct order not to run. That’s just a sound approach.

He had a designed QB run and 2 sneaks a week ago. You fire those bullets when you need them.

The only reason even JD5 got free rein to run no matter the opponent in ‘23 is because Nuss was the backup.