Favorite team:USA 
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:40072
Registered on:5/4/2005
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
Putin's latest demands should make it clear to everyone that he, and his faction, do not want peace. It's highly likely that another real conflict will be a possibility in the 2030's and 2040's given spending patterns.
quote:

Better than the route it’s currently on. Our party and our government is not working in our best interest. Similar shite was going down in Germany during Weimar. Is that extreme the solution to our own version of Weimar?


You understand that the Nazis didn't fix anything, right? As in, the solution you are proposing is the same solution that destroyed Germany. In hindsight, the mild social democracy that would have likely resulted given the make up of the German political landscape in the late 1920's would have been the far better choice than suggesting the Nazis somehow made the government of Germany work in the best interest of anyone. I mean, I guess if you are a Nazi, you would like that though.
quote:

Your Appeal to Authority argumentative approach is cute ...


Bud, I was referencing one of the origins of the argument. You read it as an appeal to authority because, and I can't repeat this enough, have incredibly poor comprehension skills.

quote:

You're probably a pretty smart individual but your egalitarian "I'm more read than all you rubes on this forum" is nauseating ...


Do you understand what egalitarian means? Because the sentence structure here suggest you do not. I'm clearly taking the snobbish route to discussion, not the egalitarian route, because I do not think you are informed enough to even have the beginnings of an opinion. That isn't an egalitarian approach. I am clearly saying, you don't have the education to form any cogent opinion.

quote:

Bass could definitely read, understand, contextualize, etc. Shakespeare and a lot of the same haute couture crap that you're throwing out here ...


Who the hell is Bass?

quote:

Now make a convincing argument vs. "hey rube, you haven't read so and so ... so you can't understand" ...


I already have, using neuroanatomy and the structure of the cerebellum itself. And apparently you haven't really reflected on the comprehension bit. At your age, it probably won't come.
quote:

So you're pointing out the limitations of output of standardized tests.


Well not merely that, but to show that standardized tests are an imperfect way of dealing with several distinct issues, from how to organize the labor of education (often referenced as student-teacher ratios) to what makes a standardized test and what doesn't, which again is also a purposeful choice. It's most obviously an immediate argument against excessive reliance on standardized tests for anything outside of the test itself. American society also isn't strictly organized along those testing lines. There are no set paths if you don't pass, university seats nor placement are directly determined by the tests and nor does a high score confer upon you some immediate placement in some program or something. There are several countries which have universal tests for college entrance, China, South Korea, India among them, but there is no part of those education systems I think the US should emulate, because the things the US does well, which is to impart things like creativity, flexible career paths, and a more varied approach to curricula. NC_Tigah's point about learning in environments where there is some limitation is actually a good example of how the US's decentralized system can still find a place for a talented individual in a demanding profession.
quote:

They could read it. Could they understand or contextually relate it to their current life, situation, history, etc?


As in, they could read it superficially, yes. Just like you superficially read my point and thought I meant the actual act of reading, rather than understanding the subtext of the plays from within the world of the play. Please for the love of all that is holy, before you respond glibly, think about what I mean when I say 'within the world of the play.' I am saying, quite clearly, that they could not understand the subtext, the context, or even a meaningful framing of the play for themselves. I would that this isn't limited to even Shakespeare, but almost all of what is regarded as the literary canon. My argument is also an older one, perhaps most visibly expressed by Randall Jarrell in The Saturday Evening Post in 1958.
quote:

Teachers want students to “fall in love with (insert topic here.)” I always laughed at the English teacher doing 6 weeks on Shakespeare to a group of kids who had less than 1 in 3 kids reading on grade level.


The vast majority of Americans cannot read Shakespeare, including well-educated members of this forum. Given I've seen directly how you reason through relatively simple texts, I would definitely include you in that group.

quote:

he first goal (and almost only) goal of education is functional knowledge.


Idiotic. Seems like you should hit Aristotle again.
quote:

In wondering what might be the cause of this, I realized that fine motor skills are more closely associated with girls whereas gross motor skills are more closely associated with boys. I wonder if the lack of emphasis on measuring fine motor skills or emphasizing their importance and potential correlation to intelligence is a result of the historical tendency to value typically-male skills and abilities?


So I wasn't completely clear here. Fine motor movement isn't by necessity associated with boys or girls. It's a fundamental human feature which the brain reserves a large amount of 'brain space' for. What I am trying to point out is that the brain networks which standardized tests tend to value don't really test the things which humans are good at, which is integrating fine motor information, as well as responding to sensory information from several centers in the brain responsible for it. What I am trying to point out is that standardized tests don't really measure but rather partition for some other purpose. I specifically mentioned boys because of my own experience working with autistic boys, where I noticed that there was wide variance between the fine motor skills and I couldn't find a consistent framework to understand the experience of that variance. It might be the case that girls are also included but might present differently, but my frame of reference for that one particular claim is strictly limited to my experience.

None of this addresses the issue, which is that for large populations, standardized tests are just convenient points to include and exclude, not maliciously, but simply by how difficult it is to tailor education to exactly how a child might learn. Motor skills in general are underrated in testing, but it is difficult to imagine that you could build a car without fine motor skills. In addition, what you need to 'build a car' is a division of labor which is compartmentalized to appropriate degrees. You need people to be limited to roles which they are good at and you need an organizational structure which can put those people into the right places in order to produce an end product.
quote:

I told her I wasn’t very happy because I’m pretty hardcore on immigration and without a border you don’t have a country. I knew she had kids so I had to say that the next time an illegal murders or rapes a US citizen, I hope the parents were one of the ones who voted for open borders and not the family of the people voting for secured borders.


You sound like an emotional psycho.
Damn. That sucks. Finding a producer is hard enough and I've had to resort to finding people through word of mouth to play parts for instruments I need. It's been a massive in the arse to find people to play certain parts for sheet music I've written and to play it and record it with any fidelity. I should save for a producer, or more specifically, an engineer, who can coordinate that work. It sucks working a ton and trying to continue this while balancing having a family. Hopefully you guys can get in the studio and finish.
quote:

But the idea that we haven't dumbed down the tests, adjusted the tests for various -isms and phobias ... and any standardized tests don't test cognitive ability is an exercise in futility when arguing with someone who doesn't have a baseline syllogistic background (not you, OP) ... outside of straw men, appeals to authority, yada, yada, yada ...


Bud, we didn't have any system of tests that were used 100+ years, so I'm glad you dropped that notion so quickly. We had 'tests' the character of which was more in the classical tradition, and for which we don't really have a direct reference save for a few fields. When Oppenheimer and several others returned from Europe in the late 20's and early 30's and built the Physics departments which are foundational for later American success in the physical sciences, it certainly wasn't built on standardized tests. There's a better argument to be made on what education we should value if we are referencing those periods, and notably, it isn't the one you seem to be advocating. Again, I don't think you care about the difference.

quote:

Your honor ... the defense rests.


I'm sure that's what you think.
quote:

Seriously though, it was being forced to compensate for my fine tremor (e.g., w/ hypothenar stabilizing) that led to real procedural successes in both accuracy and efficiency. JFK worked through a similar issue with dyslexia.


That's a really good point. There are a few artists, I think Matisse among them, that purposefully worked around constraints to help them creatively. I think there is something to say about that with early childhood learning as well.
Ha, I won't only because I like to protect my anonymity. What issues are you guys having with recording? It seems like things are going better than the last time we talked about music.
quote:

How did he start a war that started in 1979?


By not understanding why it remained a proxy conflict during that time.
Nah, the more pertinent reason is that Iran has been a cogent political entity for a long time, and occupies a very important geopolitical position, and has since antiquity. They are just very difficult to dislodge in general.
Hey bud, I was going to ask if you made any headway with your music stuff recently? Honestly asking, not trying to be a dick. I remember we talked about it last spring maybe?
Well I am not talking about 'movement,' I'm more referring to what the human brain reserves quite a lot of activity for, which is the coordination of movement. It's also true that movement is a much more highly conserved feature of mammals than something like 'intelligence' and thus harder to separate meaningfully with a battery of tests that are useful and predictive. And given the American emphasis on sports, we do value that quite a bit.

It's just that kinesthetic intelligence is underrated through standardization efforts, or most visibly so.
quote:

- US Industrial/Manufacturing Revolution (too many inventions to count)
- Nuclear power
- Countless breakthroughs in medicine
- Put a man on the moon


This isn't exactly accurate, in terms of the order of events. Describing that standardized testing worked for the US Industrial/Manufacturing Revolution is just an odd historical anachronism, especially the first wave of it, which took place between the 1790's and the 1860's. The second wave, between 1870s and up until WWI, also didn't really rely on standardized tests in any way. We didn't have standardized tests in the same way then, and it's just a lot more complicated than you are suggesting. For example, there was lots of foundational work in physics done at Gottigen, and there in the 1920s, you had Max Born, Pascual Jordan, Paul Dirac, Maria Goppert, James Franck, David Hilbert, Werner Heisenberg, John von Neumann and Robert Oppenheimer, among many others in Europe at the time. The test that they would be familiar with, at least those of them that were from Germany, would have been the Abitur, and people like Oppenheimer didn't really encounter them. I could go on, but I'm likely talking to someone who doesn't care.

quote:

It's almost like history tells a different story from the version collectivists want to tell ...


Buddy, given your treatment of the material in your post, I don't think you have a very strong grasp of that history.
quote:

It's weird that we don't try to find a better tool for measuring education. We just keep forcing standardized tests.


It's not really 'weird' at all. It's just the simplest way of partitioning talent. It's the same as with any talent partitioning system, as you just choose arbitrary cut-offs, which doesn't really capture what individuals are capable of. It can both be the case that standardized tests will miss subsections of any population because they cannot test everything, as their purpose is more about partitioning rather than testing, from a broad societal view. Raj Chetty has a paper about inventors and background that is very interesting. You should read it.
quote:

That is the ticket.


One thing I think standardized tests 'under-test' that is useful from an economic sense is fine motor skills. A massive amount of brain neural activity is dedicated to the intersection motor coordination and timing. The cerebellum, if I recall, has around 70 billion of the brain's 90 billion neurons, and it controls balance, coordination of movements and muscle tone maintenance, and the cerebrocerebellum has the nonmotor functions of cognition, language, learning and emotions. In addition, the cortical homunculus, the hands are over-represented, and the density of distinct receptors in the fingers suggest their importance in discerning touch, texture, vibration, and stretch. The problem with this notion is that acts like reading are coordinated by I believe the vestibulocerebellum, which calibrates motor neuron commands from the brainstem nuclei of CN III, IV, and VI to coordinate eye movement.

Separating fine motor skills from the motor skills that make cognition, language, and learning possible is very sensitive, although there is a neuroanatomical way of separating them. What I mean to suggest is that the biggest area where standardized tests fail students is in a subset of boys in particular where fine motor movement and coordination are not thought of as a type of intelligence even though they should absolutely be regarded as such. That's one area where the standardized approach to large populations is particularly inefficient, in my view. Your thoughts?
quote:

I don't know that there is a standardized way to measure student success. Students aren't standardized. People are different and demonstrate their abilities through different media.


This is absolutely true, but the primary issue is that there isn't a standardized way of partitioning talent efficiently in large states such that standardized tests can serve as a sieve which directs talents to areas that are both potentially economically beneficial as well as beneficial for society.

re: Voters 18-30

Posted by crazy4lsu on 11/4/26 at 3:36 pm to
I mean, I've never said I thought it was that, and I am right about all this too. Again, after looking through the older archival accounts from both the New Deal and the post-war era, I would argue that the fundamental shift in American life was architectural, made possible by the Housing Acts of 1949 and 1954, which brought on 'urban renewal,' which displaced an incredible amount of people, but also destroyed historic neighborhoods in several cities (something like 2400 cities in the US) and arguably set the stage for the nature of how the Civil Rights Movement took place in the US. Concurrently, the slow loss of the state hospital system in favor of smaller, more localized clinics, which were promised funding from administration after administration, and didn't receive it, now mean American streets in major cities are now the refuge of people who need long-term psychiatric care.

There are solutions to all of this, or we can pretend in some magical world that you can match precisely what makes an area 'livable' just by virtue of having available housing in that area.