Favorite team:
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:161
Registered on:12/31/2024
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message

re: Bama feeling some vindication tonight?

Posted by D3Fan on 1/10/26 at 12:56 am to
"What good teams did Oregon beat this year? An extremely over-rated Texas Tech?

Iowa?"

Iowa must not be too bad. They beat a Vanderbilt team that a bunch of SEC folks thought should be in the playoffs.
Indiana romped in both but if you think you'd rather have had Alabama's result than Oregon's, you're kidding yourself. Mendoza's brother played. Let that sink in.
Alabama doesn't get to pretend like they are anywhere in Oregon's league. Indiana won comfortably but they never had the game so in hand that they put in Mendoza's brother. Oregon scored 3 touchdowns.
At no point did Indiana bringing in Mendoza's BROTHER in this game. Alabama lost a lot worse and not even close.
Oregon is missing some key RB personnel. Oregon would beat Alabama. Don't try to feel better about Alabama based on today's game.
Oregon is missing some key running backs. Don't compare Alabama to Oregon to try and make yourself feel better about the SEC.

re: So. Game over. What else is on?

Posted by D3Fan on 1/9/26 at 7:06 pm to
Oregon already scored more than Alabama. And before SEC fans scream it's only Alabama, Alabama had the only regular season win over UGA.
"As a conference you dimwit."

You are pumping up the SEC conference after this post-season?

What win are you most proud of? Ole Miss beating UGA? Which SEC playoff team beat another P4 conference team?
"Another caviat coaches groomed in the SEC taking over programs like Oregon and Indiana."

The word is "caveat." Where was Nick Saban groomed before winning it all at LSU?
"what this proves is you don't need to have any accomplishments during the regular season anymore. College football is now the NFL"

Only 12 teams out of the 100 or so FBS schools make the playoffs. So you need that accomplishment.

What's the alternative? Just going off the regular season alone? What "accomplishments" did UGA have from the regular season? A great win against Alabama? We see what that was worth after the Indiana-Alabama game.
Or maybe we're actually making teams earn it on the field instead of through the media. The playoffs are important because we don't have enough data points just through regular season play to know who is truly the best.
Oregon would be a betting favorite for sure against UGA on a neutral field. Same with Ohio State.
"UGA ended with 12 wins, and won the SEC Championship. Indiana has an argument but to say Oregon or Ohio St is any better than us is ridiculous. Ohio St got thumped by a Miami team that lost to Louisville and SMU, both of whom had 4 losses on the season. UGA had 2 losses to Bama and Ole Miss, 2 playoff teams by a combined 6 points."

I think season has shown that any argument along the lines of "we're better because we won the SEC" holds no water. See Indiana-Alabama game. I guess we'll see if Oregon can stay within 35 tonight. You are trashing Miami now? The team that beat two playoff teams from the superior SEC?
"And you're basing this ridiculous comment on what? You lost your cred here kid....be gone. "

What's your argument that UGA is better than Indiana, Oregon and Ohio State?

Indiana beat Alabama a lot worse than UGA did (never mind the one loss).

I guess we'll see if Oregon can stay within 35 of Indiana tonight.

Ohio State was a consensus top 4 team and lost a lost closer to Indiana than Alabama did. The same Alabama that has a win over UGA.

OK you go.
"Alabama was the 5th highest ranked SEC team, and the only playoff team with 3 losses.

Texas Tech isn't a good team and they don't really play in a power conference."

Alabama played for the SEC conference championship. Don't make it sound like they were some middle of the pack team in the SEC.
"So 2 teams that DIDN'T win their conferences should've been in over a team that won the SEC under the old system? Is that what you're trying to say ? Great argument, it's always a pleasure to hear what the smartest guy in the room has to say."

When conferences get as big as they have gotten, it's a lot harder to know whether being a conference champion means anything because the conference schedules can be so different. So your view is that UGA is better than Oregon because they won the SEC. That's really your argument?? UGA would be the fourth best team in the Big 10 (I'll give you they are probably better than Iowa but they aren't better than Indiana, Oregon or Ohio State).
"As I pointed out, I'm not sure why you think the Big10 is doing well in the playoffs."

Well, there is that Indiana 38-3 win over Alabama and that Oregon 23-0 win over Texas Tech. Unless Oregon loses by more than 35, they will look pretty good even in a loss.
"Bowl games are meaningless."

Very convenient for you to think this after what happened this year. Are playoff games meaningless? The SEC took some bad losses there also. Good thing they had a couple of SEC-SEC matchups to ensure that an SEC team would advance. I'm not sure Ole Miss was better than Texas Tech for example.

"I wouldn’t want to go back to the BCS era, but four teams is probably the right number."

Eight is probably the right number. At four, you might not have Oregon in there. And they are clearly no worse than the second best team in the country.
Ole Miss lost by four because of some lucky breaks. Miami was sloppy and didn't take advantage of some things. Ole Miss plays Miami 100 times and they win maybe, maybe 10.
"If we didn't have to worry about getting in the 'James Madison' into the playoffs, we'd have more room for the deserving teams......Playoffs need to be at 16."

James Madison looked at least as good against Oregon as Alabama looked in their playoff game against Indiana.