
frankenfish
Favorite team: | LSU ![]() |
Location: | Crofton, MD |
Biography: | |
Interests: | |
Occupation: | |
Number of Posts: | 845 |
Registered on: | 2/23/2008 |
Online Status: | Not Online |
Recent Posts
Message
re: Time to admit LSU got it wrong.
Posted by frankenfish on 1/3/25 at 12:22 pm
I'm not convinced Kelly is the answer, but in context he was the right choice at that time. Way back when the Hat got canned and the hire of Tom Herman fell through, Coach O made sense with his pitch- pay me less as a head coach, I’ll be the recruiting coordinator and use the money you’re not paying me to be head coach to pay the best coordinators. Aranda was that on D and he got lucky with the Slinger/Joe Brady/Joe Burrow combo, but once he won, he decided he needed the big money, and that all fell apart.
So Coach O gets fired and our new AD comes back home from A&M, and says he’s paying top dollar, but wants an established coach (that worked really well with Jimbo, but I digress.) Rumor was it was Riley from Oklahoma, but he went West (to try to avoid the SEC IMO, but what do I know?) So who fits the AD’s criteria?
Saban? He’s not leaving Bama, and just retired, so that wasn’t a possibility.
Riley? Off the board to USC.
James Franklin? Had proven to be a good coach, but not a great one, and had no real motivation to leave Penn State.
Brian Day? Not going to leave The Ohio State University.
Urban Meyer? Please…
Kiffin? Not going to fire Coach O and bring in Kiffin…
Then who? Napier was hot at the University of Louisiana Lafayette, but hadn’t proven himself on the big stage.
So Kelly’s resume was really the best fit for these criteria. Has won everywhere he’s been, three coach of the year trophies, left the program in better shape than when he go there/doesn’t have a history of flaming out. I guess another way to ask, if not Kelly, then who?
Like I said, I'm not convinced Kelly is the answer, but was anyone in their right mind saying at the time, "You know what LSU should do? Give the current DC at Notre Dame, who had only been the DC there for one season, having been at DC at Cinncinnati before that, his first HC gig?"
So Coach O gets fired and our new AD comes back home from A&M, and says he’s paying top dollar, but wants an established coach (that worked really well with Jimbo, but I digress.) Rumor was it was Riley from Oklahoma, but he went West (to try to avoid the SEC IMO, but what do I know?) So who fits the AD’s criteria?
Saban? He’s not leaving Bama, and just retired, so that wasn’t a possibility.
Riley? Off the board to USC.
James Franklin? Had proven to be a good coach, but not a great one, and had no real motivation to leave Penn State.
Brian Day? Not going to leave The Ohio State University.
Urban Meyer? Please…
Kiffin? Not going to fire Coach O and bring in Kiffin…
Then who? Napier was hot at the University of Louisiana Lafayette, but hadn’t proven himself on the big stage.
So Kelly’s resume was really the best fit for these criteria. Has won everywhere he’s been, three coach of the year trophies, left the program in better shape than when he go there/doesn’t have a history of flaming out. I guess another way to ask, if not Kelly, then who?
Like I said, I'm not convinced Kelly is the answer, but was anyone in their right mind saying at the time, "You know what LSU should do? Give the current DC at Notre Dame, who had only been the DC there for one season, having been at DC at Cinncinnati before that, his first HC gig?"
re: Sydir Mitchell, DT just committed.
Posted by frankenfish on 12/20/24 at 2:34 pm
quote:
This kid is ranked below Suggs who we lost. I’m not getting excited over someone who isn’t playing in their team’s playoff game.
I totally get this and agree we shouldn't look at all of this through purple-and-gold glasses, but I think these two play fundamentally different roles. Suggs was known for a quick first step and being a good internal pass rusher, but not being stout against the run. I don't know anything about Mitchell but I am guessing at his size he's being brought in to clog the middle (Suggs' weakness) but may not have Suggs' strength against the pass?
re: Is it too much to expect LSU football to be in the 12 team playoff every year?
Posted by frankenfish on 12/5/24 at 2:49 pm
I mean, subjectively I think not, but objectively maybe it is too much to expect it, every year. Admittedly, this is year one, but it looks like the top 4 SEC teams will get into the playoffs, but maybe most years the top 3?
So coming off of the recent signing day and knowing the impact NIL had that, and that we're losing ~50% of each recruting class to the portal then have to rebuild the team each year also through the portal, LSU would need to be at least #3 in the SEC, currently ranked as:
-UGA (3)
-TEX (5)
-Bama (11)
-TN (7)
-USC (14)
-Ole Miss (13)
-MO (21)
-UF
-Vandy
-Ark
-A&M
-Auburn
-OU
-UK
-MS St
So in order to be at least #3 a team would need to go 6-2 in the SEC. There are a lot of variable listed up there, plus injuries (what if Hilton and Guillory were healthy this year?) So I think I've talked myself into thinking it is too much to ask that LSU consistently be among the top 3 strongest programs in the SEC, year in and out, but maybe I just have low expectations.
-
So coming off of the recent signing day and knowing the impact NIL had that, and that we're losing ~50% of each recruting class to the portal then have to rebuild the team each year also through the portal, LSU would need to be at least #3 in the SEC, currently ranked as:
-UGA (3)
-TEX (5)
-Bama (11)
-TN (7)
-USC (14)
-Ole Miss (13)
-MO (21)
-UF
-Vandy
-Ark
-A&M
-Auburn
-OU
-UK
-MS St
So in order to be at least #3 a team would need to go 6-2 in the SEC. There are a lot of variable listed up there, plus injuries (what if Hilton and Guillory were healthy this year?) So I think I've talked myself into thinking it is too much to ask that LSU consistently be among the top 3 strongest programs in the SEC, year in and out, but maybe I just have low expectations.
-
re: Love these 300 lb+ OLinemen signed so far today
Posted by frankenfish on 12/4/24 at 11:36 am
I agree. Along these same lines I was wondering about Brett Bordelon. I've seen him listed at 250 and 260 and wonder how much "good weight" he can add. I know Breaux was able to come in and add weight in the off-season so it's possible; I can see adding 20 pounds but I'm thinking Brett Bordelon would need 40-50 pounds? Though Bo Bordelon is listed as 310 on the roster, so maybe it's possible...
re: Caden Durham was in for 20 plays
Posted by frankenfish on 11/12/24 at 4:27 pm
I just assumed those two dislocated toes are bothering him. I know they would me, but again, I'm just assuming that. Maybe coaches don't want to put the team in the best chance to win?
re: Chris Hilton probable vs aTm
Posted by frankenfish on 10/26/24 at 7:28 am
I know nothing about the actual situation, but it could make sense not to play Hilton this week, if he's not 100%. Give him two more weeks rest and then he's 100% for the last four regular season games and post season, and would still be eligible for a redshirt.
Redshirt rules
In football, for instance, a player can play in up to four regular-season games and still use his redshirt season (the NCAA recently updated this rule to exempt all postseason competition from the four-game policy).
I see he's listed as a red-shirt Jr., so if he can only redshirt once then this is moot; just morning thoughts over coffee.
Redshirt rules
In football, for instance, a player can play in up to four regular-season games and still use his redshirt season (the NCAA recently updated this rule to exempt all postseason competition from the four-game policy).
I see he's listed as a red-shirt Jr., so if he can only redshirt once then this is moot; just morning thoughts over coffee.
re: Bo Bordelon #89
Posted by frankenfish on 10/22/24 at 4:50 pm
I always enjoy Cole Cubelic's summary each week of each team, and noticed he mentioned Bo in his LSU report this week:
LSU: Rivalry win. Def in full attack mode. 4 great off edge. His hands are lethal. Inside & outside moves. 40 just all over the place. Seems like he's in on every single play. 35 good on the rush. They had QB on the run most of the game. Tackled well in open field again. LBs perused well. Really good vs run. Got yo k game going early. Like pocket movement for QB. Got 2 involved right away. Like how 13 climbs pocket. Changes arm angles. Good quick distribution vs high pressure. Still tries to fit it in some spots that might not be there. 66 good, had some battles with 40. He finishes though! 86 had a good game. Evened up formation & got zone runs going a little. 29 got it going. Runs low, good burst. Has a nice jump cut. RBs struggled in pass pro. 89 gets after it when in there at TE.
That's all I have...
LSU: Rivalry win. Def in full attack mode. 4 great off edge. His hands are lethal. Inside & outside moves. 40 just all over the place. Seems like he's in on every single play. 35 good on the rush. They had QB on the run most of the game. Tackled well in open field again. LBs perused well. Really good vs run. Got yo k game going early. Like pocket movement for QB. Got 2 involved right away. Like how 13 climbs pocket. Changes arm angles. Good quick distribution vs high pressure. Still tries to fit it in some spots that might not be there. 66 good, had some battles with 40. He finishes though! 86 had a good game. Evened up formation & got zone runs going a little. 29 got it going. Runs low, good burst. Has a nice jump cut. RBs struggled in pass pro. 89 gets after it when in there at TE.
That's all I have...
re: Per John Kennedy, Johnson will bring 3 bills next week. Israel, Taiwan and Ukraine.
Posted by frankenfish on 4/15/24 at 5:36 pm
quote:
If the republicans had a 40 vote majority,
But I don't feel like that's the plan. The plan is to back only those who support Trump 100%. When the republicans had such a majority, it was by getting the most conservative candidate who could be elected in that district/state elected. Now, if you aren't 100% in agreement with Trump, you are a Rino squish who MAGA says they don't need. And with that, the likelihood of getting a larger majority isn't likely. Those of you in 60% plus red districts can require that, but it's a death sentence for those of us in 50/50 districts.
re: Watching The Happiest Country on Earth: Finland on PBS
Posted by frankenfish on 4/8/24 at 5:47 pm
quote:
happy paying 57% income taxes
I'm not saying it's right, but in a smaller population that is that homogenous, you likely know more family members who have benefitted from those programs than you do folks who are ripping off the system, or you are at least willing to consider that you know some who benifit. Here I feel like I don't know anyone who benefits from gov't programs, but see lots of stories about grifters.
re: Mike Johnson was on Moon Monday
Posted by frankenfish on 4/4/24 at 1:44 pm
quote:
Moon Griffon......a lot like Hannity, but without the intelligence.
I'm not sure if that's a shot at Moon or Hannity, but it hits the mark either way.
re: Shea: Dellinger and Frazier to return to #LSU
Posted by frankenfish on 1/17/24 at 5:19 pm
quote:
I would imagine that their decision to return was a big factor in Lunsford's retirement.
And I think Heard, too. Heard wasn't beating out Campbell at LT, or Jones at right, and with Frazier coming back Jones wouldn't kick down to rigth guard to make room for Heard at right tackle, so Heard didn't see a path to playing this year. That at least makes sense to me...
re: If this has been covered my apologies, but canning the entire staff is huge.
Posted by frankenfish on 1/3/24 at 4:46 pm
quote:
Kelly has already met with multiple candidates and already has his man
I want to hope that's the case. Because if he's a worthy enough DC to stipulate part of him coming is he gets to name his position coaches, he must have enough of a track record to warrant that.
If this has been covered my apologies, but canning the entire staff is huge.
Posted by frankenfish on 1/3/24 at 4:38 pm
In the past the rumor was some big named DCs would only come if they had a say in the position coaches, and prior head coaches were insistent on keeping some position coaches (Raymond, for instance.)
Kelly can now meet with a DC candidate and say, "come work for me; we'll pay you $X and you'll have a major say in filling your position coaches, who we'll pay a total of $Y."
That really opens the door wide for candidates...
Kelly can now meet with a DC candidate and say, "come work for me; we'll pay you $X and you'll have a major say in filling your position coaches, who we'll pay a total of $Y."
That really opens the door wide for candidates...
re: Mekhi Wingo Declares for NFL DRAFT
Posted by frankenfish on 1/2/24 at 1:23 pm
I do appreciate him playing in the bowl game, but that wasn't totally unselfish. If he gave it a go and wasn't fully healed, or worst case reinjured himself, he could come back a year, but if he felt he was 100% and would test well, he could declare.
Playing in the bowl game was win-win for him.
Playing in the bowl game was win-win for him.
re: Co offensive coordinators for the bowl game!
Posted by frankenfish on 12/22/23 at 11:59 am
In that picture is sure does look like Coach O skipped leg day, amirite?
re: Co offensive coordinators for the bowl game!
Posted by frankenfish on 12/22/23 at 11:50 am
i hate to risk being a negatiger, but if one of the co-coordinators isn't made the permanent, does he then leave? I don't want to lose either of those cats.
re: So with denbrock leaving who’s going to be our next OC?
Posted by frankenfish on 12/22/23 at 10:04 am
I hear Matt Canada is available.
re: Denbrock to Notre Dame per ND Reporter
Posted by frankenfish on 12/22/23 at 9:54 am
Kelly's press conference today just got much more interesting. Any idea if that's scheduled yet?
re: Quency Wiggins hits transfer portal
Posted by frankenfish on 12/8/23 at 9:58 am
Was he the kid that got run over by a car at an all-star game? they said no effects from that, but if you saw the video, you gotta wonder...
re: Bryce Langston to portal
Posted by frankenfish on 12/3/23 at 7:06 pm
This, like L. Welch, is a rare instance of a win-win, and where the portal is good. If Langston and Welch couldn't see any PT during this season where those were obvioulsy thin positions, let them transfer out to see if they can get PT elsewhere, and let us use the portal to transfer some folks in who might contribute. As others say, best of luck to him.
Popular