User Avatar

TorchtheFlyingTiger

Favorite team:North Carolina St. 
Location:1st coast
Biography:
Interests:LSU & NC St sports, travel, finance
Occupation:FIRE'd
Number of Posts:2922
Registered on:1/14/2008
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message

Those homes look really crammed close with small lots. Quite lucky it didnt spread to neighboring homes.

Gifting shares tax free

Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger on 12/22/25 at 11:21 am
Just saved $650 tax bill by gifting appreciated shares to a relative in zero LTCG bracket. Unfortunately, they'll still get hit w 3% LA income tax but still come out ahead over $500 versus me selling and giving them post tax proceeds. (Gave a couple extra shares to cover their taxes) Been trying to do this for them for awhile but they took their time opening a brokerage account. (Guess he didn't want my $ too bad)

Next I need to start doing same for my kids but careful not to trigger kiddie tax.

Getting almost as much joy out of beating IRS as giving gifts
Is broken jaw and this surgery typically a career ender for boxers? Does the titanium stay in or would it have to be removed before returning to ring?
How is this "woke"? More like cancel culture and class divisiveness.
Kinda crazy they published the perp's home and business address including household details. Also detailed his college degree, fraternity and social affiliations.

re: 401k vs Roth 401k

Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger on 12/16/25 at 11:48 am to
RMDs dont start until 75 (earlier for those born before 1960).
Brackets are likely to increase w/ inflation. (especially lowest brackets) Even today you'd have to exceed $394k plus deductions (married joint) before next dollar is taxed at 32%. So, even if in 32% bracket, effective tax rate of withdrawals would likely be much lower.

With RMDs delayed until 75, that gives early and even regular retirees a lengthy window for Roth conversions if desired.

re: 401k vs Roth 401k

Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger on 12/14/25 at 1:18 pm to
quote:

If I did the roll over all at once, and I’m already in the 32% bracket, would it be on just the contributions or contributions plus gains?

If you convert trad IRA to Roth the entire conversion is taxable (you didn't pay tax on contributions so any growth is also taxable). Converting at 32% probably isnt a great idea (no different than the Roth 401k contributions you're considering tax wise). On other hand, rollover from IRA to 401k isnt a taxable event.
I've heard of cases where HS or college aged kids have committed suicide over sextortion. Had to warn my kids about over sharing online and how embarrassing predicaments are never worth offing oneself no matter how dire it seems. Somehow this seems like a more implausible reaction though less severe/tragic.

re: 401k vs Roth 401k

Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger on 12/14/25 at 3:15 am to
32% today 24% projected at retirement, sounds like traditional is probably the way to go. Plus, the effective tax rate on traditional withdrawals would be even lower unless you have other income sources filling the bottom brackets. Simply comparing current and future marginal rates often overlooks the benefit of filling lowest brackets with tax deferred traditional withdrawals.

If you want to build more in Roth as well for future tax optimization consider Roth conversions on spouse's trad IRA so she can backdoor. Or, better yet rollover into her current 401k if possible.

re: 401k vs Roth 401k

Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger on 12/13/25 at 2:58 pm to
quote:

 I may be able to draw that my first year or two and show little to no income. Could supplement out of my brokerage accounts to be low income for those years.



Typically Roth is last thing you want to tap. Best left to grow tax free. Plus, better to draw down traditional first before SS stacked on top and taxed and before higher taxable income triggers IRMAA. May be a case for Roth first for ACA subsidies and zero LTCG rate etc but often not the optimal solution. As others have said having some of both gives you options to optimize tax strategies later but may not be worth paying high rate now.

re: 401k vs Roth 401k

Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger on 12/13/25 at 2:51 pm to
Traditional contributions save you at your top marginal rate today but on withdrawal it is taxed at your effective rate which could be much lower especially if little or no other taxable income source.
Schwab, Fidelity, Vanguard or even Robinhood (although I'll take heat for this). Read JL Collins' Simple Path to Wealth and if it makes sense manage it yourself. If you think you need help at least you have a baseline of knowledge to work from when vetting an advisor or picking a roboadvisor.
So you already know everyone here is going to tell you not to use an insurance firm for investments.
I played around awhile back with the free versions or trials a few of these tools. I havent pulled the trigger on a subscription yet. I'm still need to find the best one to meet my needs (tax optimized withdrawal strategy and Roth conversions). This guy reviews Boldin and several others you might want to try 5 Best Retirement Calculators Rob Berger
Reading up on boggleheads, reddit etc, users that tried more than one typically observed they give different results and recommendations due to different default assumptions.
Best tool is going to be dependent on what you are looking for it to do and what you are willing to spend.

re: Insurance claim

Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger on 12/4/25 at 9:12 pm to
quote:

He owns the car but under our insurance

How does this work? I didn't realize this was a thing people did. Is he not insurable himself? And why would you potentially open yourself up to liability or rate hikes if he makes a claim on your policy?
You may not want to burst her bubble. Best for her to have more situational awareness and head on swivel in future anyway. Besides, probably feeds her self esteem to believe she was chosen as a target amongst all the other women shoppers.
Who do you think is making decision to have babies for this $1k account? It isnt accessible to parent anyway. Anyone with the long term perspective to consider what these may be worth in 18 years isnt making babies because of it. If investment accounts is their motivator, personal financial costs of child rearing far exceed the $1k.

Increased child tax credit would perhaps create some immediate winners.

Even if there is a play here it would be in 18+ yrs when irresponsible young adults raid their own accounts.
Lump sum right back into the market. Dont fool yourself, converting to cash and sitting on sideline is market timing not true DCA.
I would stick to index funds for vast majority of portfolio and if taking any higher risk/reward do it in tax advantaged where you dont worry about tax consequences of trades.
I dont like dividend plays but if you must, avoid holding in taxable where they will suffer tax drag. No need to generate extra taxable dividend income you dont need.
If you are already competent self managing, 1% for an advisor is more than I'd want to spend. I'd try to find a fee only advisor to QC your plan occasionally and perhaps focus on tax optimized allocation, conversion and withdrawal strategies. You probably get more benefit from good tax professional in short term.
Diversification into other asset classes is probably good idea.
As for building out commercial real estate and active trading, be sure to weigh the value of your time. Even if you enjoy it now, it might be an unnecessary mental burden in a market downturn. Your time is likely better spent in your field of expertise.
Looking back, is this the same $15k you plan to spend on a car for your son? (Posted back in Aug planning to buy in a yr talk-me-out-of-a-401k-loan ) If you have to mortgage ypur home to make it happen, you simply cant afford to buy it for him. I didnt have a car until junior year of college because I worked but didnt save. If you must, just take out an auto loan from local credit union. Many offer low auto rates to bring in customers. Arkansas Federal CU is advertising as low as 3.99% for example.

Borrowing against your retirement or home to buy a depreciating asset for a child is financially reckless.
More reason to wait. You'd be unnecessarily accruing an additional 8 months of higher interest rate on existing equity loan balance. It might make more sense to keep the lower rate and borrow the $15k when needed on a separate HELOC or personal loan, especially if the existing loan is high balance.
Take it now means you will start accruing interest on the entire $15k (plus possibly higher rate.on existing home equity loan balance). Better to set aside the extra payments you'd be making and borrow less when time comes that you actually need it. What is your current home equity loan rate?