therick711

I don't really talk about this, but my Dad was a mailman who loved Bad Bunny.

It can't be stolen if no one is illegal. Way to flame the board, dummy.

Not really. Denmark had the right to veto any military installations and we did not have the right to install ballistic missile sites, the whole point of wanting that location. Now, Denmark is reportedly no longer able to veto US military plans in Green-a-Lago.

Just as long as we are clear that you were completely wrong about both the state of the law and practice in this area since the founding. Your disagreement on how it may turn out is a long way away from your original thesis. I admire when someone can admit they were wrong. :cheers:

Sure it is. The Senate exercises advise and consent on nominations and the president can then unilaterally fire cabinet heads, recall ambassadors, fire us attorneys. It would actually fit much better in the framework for it to be as everyone since Washington assumed.

Also, the congress attempted to impose this condition in the 2024 ndaa, not as a ratification of NATO which occurred in 1949.

quote:

---

And when Congress requires approval before withdrawal as a condition of its approval?

---

Why would they even have to do that if the president didn't have that power, though. QED.

quote:

---

What would be the point of a requirement that the Senate approve of a treaty if POTUS can unilaterally withdraw from it?

---

Washington and Jefferson apparently disagree with you. The president must receive advice and consent to enter obligations to other countries, but can terminate obligations under his foreign affair article II powers.

No it won't. The supreme court abstained under its political question doctrine. Congress would have to impeach and convict that the senate is required to terminate. That's the landscape. Interesting that you would speak so definitively on the issue given you haven't really looked at it.

As to impeachment, would be very difficult to justify given Washington, Jefferson, Carter, Reagan, both Bushes, and Trump twice have all done it unilaterally.

Making treaties. The president has always had the power to withdraw from them.

You don't really have a risk of not finding anything. You have a great case of felony murder on video. She should stand trial for it.