
Ice Cold
Favorite team: | USA ![]() |
Location: | Over Macho Grande |
Biography: | |
Interests: | |
Occupation: | |
Number of Posts: | 18766 |
Registered on: | 6/8/2004 |
Online Status: | Not Online |
Recent Posts
Message
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/20/25 at 6:53 am
quote:You make some good points about the writers' plot choices. Before Reghabi left, I assumed the end game was for Mark to reintegrate and continue working. He would be doing recon on a daily basis, feeding info to Reghabi, and searching for wife. Who knows how long that would take.
i get they had to move the plot along so whatever, it doesn't explain why once they meet with Cobel they don't question a thing she says or follow up on Cold Harbor cause outtie mark and Davon have no idea what in the world she is talking about.
OTOH, Devon is the driver for this choice, and she knows nothing about the severed floor. All she knows is that she saw her brother collapse, foam at the mouth, and sleep for a day (or days?) because of Reghabi, and she wants nothing more to do with that. Cobel is the only other person she knows who could help. As it turns out, she and Mark now know that Cold Harbor is related to Gemma, and they wouldn't have known that working with Reghabi.
So I agree it could have gone another way, but it didn't, and I'm OK with it.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/17/25 at 9:51 am
quote:It occurred to me that Cobel arrive in broad daylight and they all hung out until night fell. WTF did they talk about the whole time? Share recipes? Reminisce about how Cobel pretended to be a lactation consultant for his sister and her baby?
Nobody really wants “natural” dialogue in a TV drama, IMO. It wouldn’t be that enjoyable to watch. Part of the trick with good writing & acting is to capture the essence of those interactions in a way that allows the viewer to understand the characters’ motivations and reactions in a way that feels natural without actually being natural.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/14/25 at 2:01 pm
quote:Didn't answer my question about whether Mark went in.
Not all the cabins are severance cabins.
If your statement is true, was that explained at some point? I don't remember. Why would Lumon not have all cabins (at a birthing center it controls) outfitted for the tech?
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/14/25 at 12:49 pm
I thought this episode was great and don't get the downvotes on people who say that. Folks were complaining about the show's pace, and Ep9 was jam-packed with developments and moved several arcs forward.
Here were my immediate thoughts after the episode; I do not vouch for their insight or correctness. I also haven't read a single thing yet about this episode.
1. Jame is a breeder.
2. Did Helena tip off Burt? Some have suggested it was Helly, not Helena, but how would Helly have all the information necessary to impersonate Helena at their family home, contact Burt, etc.
I think Helena tipped off Burt, and Jame's statement to Helly in MDR is because he doesn't know she started severing again after the gala. Remember that Drummond and Natalie did not tell Jame what happened at ORTBO, that she slept with Mark and that Irv forced her innie.
Also, Helly sounds like a regular nickname for Helena, so it would not surprise me that her dad calls her that.
3. Why did Milchick treat Eustace (???) Huang so harshly? Is she an Eagan prodigy like Cobel?
4. Did anyone hear Jame moan (as if experiencing sexual pleasure) when Helena started to cut her egg? And that when she asked if he would join her, he said "I'll watch" as if he were a voyeur?
5. I agree with what someone else said in this thread that Dylan did not leave the building. The scene cut to the testing floor elevator and hallway right after he got into the main elevator. And it took a while for that elevator to arrive; why would they have delayed his departure like that?
6 . I still don't know how the severance tech works. Is it geo-located like GPS? Is it a physical barrier? A combination? How did Devon know the cabin would work on Mark?
7. I thought reintegration mitigated or eliminated the innie/outie distinction, but Mark was full innie after entering the cabin. If he climbed out a window, would he still be his innie?
8. Yes, the Dylan arc is heartbreaking. So sad that his innie thought his outie would be happy for his innie to get some.
9. You could see the flip switch with Milchick. And he was absolutely, positively, 100% right that he's only responsible for what happens on the floor. fricking fantastic scene.
10. Has anyone gone back to see what the Artetas' kids look like? I wonder if they are Jame's children.
11. Did Mark ever go into the birthing cabin when Devon had her baby? The midwife opened the door to leave and they talked outside, but I don't remember him going in.
Here were my immediate thoughts after the episode; I do not vouch for their insight or correctness. I also haven't read a single thing yet about this episode.
1. Jame is a breeder.
2. Did Helena tip off Burt? Some have suggested it was Helly, not Helena, but how would Helly have all the information necessary to impersonate Helena at their family home, contact Burt, etc.
I think Helena tipped off Burt, and Jame's statement to Helly in MDR is because he doesn't know she started severing again after the gala. Remember that Drummond and Natalie did not tell Jame what happened at ORTBO, that she slept with Mark and that Irv forced her innie.
Also, Helly sounds like a regular nickname for Helena, so it would not surprise me that her dad calls her that.
3. Why did Milchick treat Eustace (???) Huang so harshly? Is she an Eagan prodigy like Cobel?
4. Did anyone hear Jame moan (as if experiencing sexual pleasure) when Helena started to cut her egg? And that when she asked if he would join her, he said "I'll watch" as if he were a voyeur?
5. I agree with what someone else said in this thread that Dylan did not leave the building. The scene cut to the testing floor elevator and hallway right after he got into the main elevator. And it took a while for that elevator to arrive; why would they have delayed his departure like that?
6 . I still don't know how the severance tech works. Is it geo-located like GPS? Is it a physical barrier? A combination? How did Devon know the cabin would work on Mark?
7. I thought reintegration mitigated or eliminated the innie/outie distinction, but Mark was full innie after entering the cabin. If he climbed out a window, would he still be his innie?
8. Yes, the Dylan arc is heartbreaking. So sad that his innie thought his outie would be happy for his innie to get some.
9. You could see the flip switch with Milchick. And he was absolutely, positively, 100% right that he's only responsible for what happens on the floor. fricking fantastic scene.
10. Has anyone gone back to see what the Artetas' kids look like? I wonder if they are Jame's children.
11. Did Mark ever go into the birthing cabin when Devon had her baby? The midwife opened the door to leave and they talked outside, but I don't remember him going in.
re: “Captain America: Brave New World” one of the lowest-grossing Marvel movies of all-time
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/14/25 at 12:29 pm
quote:Exactly. No other actor - let alone character* - could step into that role. The combination of super soldier with a heart of gold could not be replicated.
To me it's more that Mackie isn't Captain America (really). Whether Disney wants to admit it or not, Chris Evans is Captain America,
*I had thought that if anyone could, Bucky Barnes could. You need the super soldier part, because otherwise Cap is just a nice guy with tools. US Agent took the serum, but didn't have the character. Bucky had the character, and no one was closer to Steve. It doesn't make a lot of sense in the first place that Steve picked Sam and Bucky smiled at that.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/11/25 at 2:30 pm
quote:Cut into four pieces, it is. :alien:
The egg bar is coveted as frick.
re: JoBlo has been uploading greatest Gene Hackman scenes
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/11/25 at 2:26 pm
Holy crap I forgot he was in "No Way Out." What a friggin' movie that is.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/10/25 at 2:25 pm
quote:Hence her statement to Helena, "You fear me." Helena seemingly brushed that off.
So Harmony is Lumon and they cheated her out of it.
We don't know who was driving up to the aunt's house as she drove away. That will tell us how important was her trip to Salt's Neck.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/6/25 at 10:03 am
quote:I felt the ORTBO episode had a lot of dead air, particularly the scenes of them just walking. They didn't need all of that to set up the confrontation between Irv and Helena.
I'm pretty sensitive to any episode padding.But I really don't think this show has done that at all this season. Every episode is necessary and produces interesting new information and plot developments.
And speaking of that episode, it didn't make sense that Milchick and Huang were not monitoring the innies closely, especially knowing that Helena was in the mix. Just odd for Lumon not to exercise more control - not less - when venturing from the severed floor.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/3/25 at 9:40 am
quote:Can you imagine living every moment of your existence in a dentist's office? Writing thank you notes? Feeling like your plane is falling out of the sky? Or even working in a drab, windowless office with psychopathic managers? That's literally ALL YOU EXPERIENCE???
She comes out with her teeth hurting.
Helena calls innies "animals," which implies they have no consciousness, no self-awareness, no philosophy of mind. We don't talk enough about how unspeakably cruel that is.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/3/25 at 9:36 am
quote:We still don't know how Irv knows about that door, which Cobel calls the testing floor and which the O&D woman called the "Exports Hall."
When Milkshake sends Mrs Casey back, the elevator with teh arrow down, is that was Irv was seeing in his paintings? Like leading down to that floor to what they do to her?
We also don't know who Irv is talking to on the pay phone.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 3/3/25 at 9:34 am
quote:Which makes Helena shagging a man in a tent in that same forest -- a man who appears to be Lumon's most important innie of all time (Cold Harbor being the greatest moment in the company's history) -- a big EFF EWE to Jame and her ancestors.
Dieter isn’t a twin. Dieter is Kier’s innie. Dieter got high on either and jerked off. Kier was disgusted and wanted to purge himself of that part of himself.
Call me crazy, but I don't think Helena has mastered the four humors yet.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/28/25 at 3:28 pm
quote:I was wondering from the start if Kier is a company town, and it has many of the hallmarks. On the other hand, there's the Whole Mind Collective, the news show earlier this year that had on a vocal Lumon critic, and the underground punk scene actively defying Lumon.
- the dawning realization that all of Kier is Lumon and wondering how Mark and Gemma wound up there in the first place
Gemma's "death" suggests Lumon has some high level of influence over the police, and the company has infiltrated every aspect of local life. I wonder if we'll ever get to see the legal, geographical, and philosophical limits of Kier.
And with whom is Irv speaking on the pay phone far away from his townhouse?
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/28/25 at 9:17 am
quote:
jevins_slickin
quote::bow: :bow: :bow:
Im like 80% sure on this.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/28/25 at 9:16 am
quote:Have to think Lumon engineered the miscarriage(s) and failed attempts, given the doc's presence in the medical office they visited. I wonder if the doc survived after FAFO. What an nightmarishly creepy role.
Wonder if Lumon was preventing her getting pregnant with those shots.
I don't think the plan has been for Gemma to die, even though Drummond said the doc wouldn't see her again after Cold Harbor. Sounded like the doc was laying the groundwork for her to stay with him.
Goodness gracious, so much to say about episode, down to:
- realizing that Gemma is there by choice (even if Lumon coerced her) and that she wants to reunite with Mark
- each Gemma innie's total existence being limited to a world of pain, discomfort, and some type of relationship with the doctor
- the weirdness of the testing floor room where the innies' every move is watched
- the visual juxtapositions of Mark and Gemma as they grew apart
- Mark's stunned countenance when he realized the police were outside his door
- Milchick intercepting Casey in the hallway and turning her around
- the realization on Gemma's face when she finds herself back on the testing floor
- the trauma of Gemma's miscarriage
- the normalcy of Mark/Gemma/Devon/Ricken eating lunch
- the dawning realization that all of Kier is Lumon and wondering how Mark and Gemma wound up there in the first place
I could go on ... I'm stilled stunned.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/27/25 at 10:13 pm
That might be one of the best episodes of television I’ve ever watched. At turns joyful, terrifying, confounding, creepy, layered, devastating - absolutely brilliant. And yes, Lumon officially does what it wants wherever it wants whenever it wants to whomever it wants.
ETA: And Mark might finally be ready to frick up some Eagan shite. Helena don’t even know.
ETA: And Mark might finally be ready to frick up some Eagan shite. Helena don’t even know.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/26/25 at 8:16 am
quote:Gonna have to disagree with you there. Part of Dylan's original badassness was that he had no conception of what's upstairs. He talked about people living underwater because the Earth was so messed up. He had no frame of reference for the outside world. He kicked arse at his job and has the finger traps to prove it. He assumed his outie kicked arse also.
Dylan was "bad arse" in the first season, to now be pussy whipped in season 2.
Then he had a glimpse of his son in the closet with Milchick (not gay) and learned a lot more about possibilities through Ricken, O&D, and the OTC incident. Now he's hearing from his outie's wife that his outie is not a badass, has trouble keeping jobs, and seems to be a "frick up." Then he makes out with her. Milchick and Huang don't appear to be monitoring the visitation room, so who knows where that goes?
Anyhoo, every character is on a journey. I don't see it as weakening at all.
re: John Lithgow Confirmed to play Dumbledore
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/26/25 at 8:07 am
quote:I did not care for him as Churchill in The Crown. To my ear, his English accent is poor, and for the life of me, I couldn't understand why they cast him in that role.
On one hand, I love Lithgow but on the other hand i think they should have gone with someone a bit younger.
But props to him in general for continuing to grind when he's 80.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/25/25 at 1:55 pm
quote:I dunno, man. We're watching an outie's wife fall in love with his innie.
Dylan/Gretchen - The story line seems too generic and overused for a show with interesting new angles.
This raises all sorts of metaphysical and philosophical questions, not the least of which are (1) do they consummate and (2) does she accept a segmented relationship with his innie as the cost of staying with his outie? I doubt the series will answer them all, but it's very interesting to me.
re: Severance Season 2 Discussion (Spoilers)
Posted by Ice Cold on 2/25/25 at 1:46 pm
quote:Which Burt ends with an explicit invitation to Irv that they get together without Fields. Wild, wild stuff...
Here is a very intelligent and crazy weird show, this is the 3-gay dinner scene - enjoy!
Popular