re: Deuce McAllister or Shaun Alexander: who was better in college?

quote:

---

Deuce. And it ain't close. Those bama teams were talented.

---

Shaun Alexander won an SEC title his senior season in 99 and then the year after he left, the 2000 Bama team won a total of 3 games including being shut out offensively by Southern Miss. That was a different Bama era than you are used to now.

quote:

---

Evidenced by the fact Alexander was always voted among the most overrated players. Even by peers. Deuce was widely respected.

---

Shaun won an NFL MVP award. For 5 or 6 years he was consistently a top 5 pick in fantasy drafts. If he was ever overrated, it was because his expectations were literally as high as they can possibly be.