re: Would Bama have won as much or more with Manziel at QB instead of McCarron?

quote:

---

He had a good year, and the hype went to the max after A&M beat Alabama.

That doesn't mean hes the best player for another team or an automatic win elsewhere.

---

So you don't think he deserved those awards? Did you forget his performances versus Bama and Oklahoma? He is a much better athlete than AJ and any CFB QB that year but he can't play in a structured offense which is the only reason he wouldn't do well at Bama.