re: Bama fans, Does LCollins start over Vinnie?

quote:

---

and that is a lot more than LC did his FR year. In a year when DB play was needed, LC still couldn't get on the field.

---

Ok? Barron didn't get on the field either as a Freshman, so what? Vinnie was a coaches son and probably a suck up.

quote:

---

Disagree, and obviously not as big of liability as LC would have been.

---

Saban went with experience over talent. If you really think Vinnie, who constantly showed his lack of athleticism to cover slots, can outperform LC at anything football related other than maybe run stopping and blitzing, I don't know what to say.

quote:

---

welcome to CFB, care for me to show how many times "the great" Milliner was burned last year.

---

A few. Any great player has bad moments. Vinnie's moments were tackles. I'm not saying he'd be horrible as just a Safety/Money, he'd be good, but LC would be better as a Safety next to HCD.

quote:

---

Goal is winning Nat'l Titles, Vinnie has contributed for two Titles.

---

No one should be satisfied with winning National Titles if it's in doubt. We lost the last two years, this past season we played too many close games, I don't care how good those teams were. A title isn't good enough if people have reason to doubt it. With the talent and coaching we have we should be blowing people out ala 2011 style, but in 2011 we did drop a game to another elite team. We can go over the reasons we lost and why we were truly a better team all we want, but the fact is we lost and that isn't acceptable, even if we still win a title. If just winning a title is seen as acceptable, then the players should just rest during the A&M game and dominate everyone else, because hey we can lose and still win a title! No, just no.