Started By
Message

re: Nick Saban and the NFL Draft

Posted on 4/21/12 at 11:52 am to
Posted by UASports23
Member since Nov 2009
24354 posts
Posted on 4/21/12 at 11:52 am to
quote:

Meanwhile, AU players who have been drafted have excelled and have make All-Pro.


Let's re-visit AU's last few first rounders and use your logic of what a first rounder should be.

Logic:
quote:

So being pretty good and solid is worth a first round draft pick. I would agree if you were drafting based on Raiders Standards.



Ronnie Brown (First rounder, 1 Pro Bowl, 4.2 per carry. 37 TDS) BUST

Cadillac Williams (First rounder, 3.8 yds per carry, only 20 TDs in his career, Not even in the NFL anymore? I know short lifetime for RBs) BUST

Ben Grubbs (First Rounder, been very solid but only 1 Pro Bowl)

Jason Campbell (First Rounder, been on what 3 teams?..Raiders, Redskins, Bears) BUST

Cam Newton, (#1 overall, Has been a BEAST, no one can argue this)

Nick Fairly (stayed hurt only had 15 tackles, 1 Sack in his rookie year, Dareus blew him out of the water last year. Will it keep up. I'm not sure, no one knows.) BUST

Carlos Rogers (2nd All Pro, 1 Pro Bowl, 6 Years after being in the NFL) BUST


Yea, you're right dude. AU produces much of a better first rounder prospect than 'Bama. I'm not even saying 'Bama's first rounders are going to be studs. I'm just pointing out that you're full of shite.

The NFL is a gamble. For every, good player a school produces I can name you 2 bad ones. That is for everyone. Plus, right now....'Bama is just now getting back in the NFL. Because of our probation, scholarship numbers, and overall talent that we had in the past.

They guys we are producing now has been better than the last 10 years.
This post was edited on 4/21/12 at 12:04 pm
Posted by Irons Puppet
Birmingham
Member since Jun 2009
25901 posts
Posted on 4/21/12 at 12:25 pm to
quote:

Ronnie Brown (First rounder, 1 Pro Bowl, 4.2 per carry. 37 TDS) BUST

Cadillac Williams (First rounder, 3.8 yds per carry, only 20 TDs in his career, Not even in the NFL anymore? I know short lifetime for RBs) BUST

Ben Grubbs (First Rounder, been very solid but only 1 Pro Bowl)

Jason Campbell (First Rounder, been on what 3 teams?..Raiders, Redskins, Bears) BUST

Cam Newton, (#1 overall, Has been a BEAST, no one can argue this)

Nick Fairly (stayed hurt only had 15 tackles, 1 Sack in his rookie year, Dareus blew him out of the water last year. Will it keep up. I'm not sure, no one knows.) BUST

Carlos Rogers (2nd All Pro, 1 Pro Bowl, 6 Years after being in the NFL) BUST


Thank you for re-writing history with the word Bust.

Brown-Pro Bowler, leading rusher for the Dolphins
Cadillac- Rookie of the Year
Grubbs- Pro Bowler
Rogers- Pro Bowler
Newton- Rookie of the Year
McNeil- Pro Bowler
Dansby-Pro Bowler
Washington- Pro Bowler
Ratlif- Multi-Pro Bowler

Tate- shares time with the leading rusher in the league and still almost has 1000 yrd season.

They are all bust.

Posted by CFBFAN1121
Abbottabad, Pakistan
Member since Sep 2006
4174 posts
Posted on 4/21/12 at 2:53 pm to
quote:


Ronnie Brown (First rounder, 1 Pro Bowl, 4.2 per carry. 37 TDS) BUST

Cadillac Williams (First rounder, 3.8 yds per carry, only 20 TDs in his career, Not even in the NFL anymore? I know short lifetime for RBs) BUST

Ben Grubbs (First Rounder, been very solid but only 1 Pro Bowl)

Jason Campbell (First Rounder, been on what 3 teams?..Raiders, Redskins, Bears) BUST

Cam Newton, (#1 overall, Has been a BEAST, no one can argue this)

Nick Fairly (stayed hurt only had 15 tackles, 1 Sack in his rookie year, Dareus blew him out of the water last year. Will it keep up. I'm not sure, no one knows.) BUST

Carlos Rogers (2nd All Pro, 1 Pro Bowl, 6 Years after being in the NFL) BUST


Yea, you're right dude. AU produces much of a better first rounder prospect than 'Bama. I'm not even saying 'Bama's first rounders are going to be studs. I'm just pointing out that you're full of shite.

The NFL is a gamble. For every, good player a school produces I can name you 2 bad ones. That is for everyone. Plus, right now....'Bama is just now getting back in the NFL. Because of our probation, scholarship numbers, and overall talent that we had in the past.

They guys we are producing now has been better than the last 10 years.


This is quite funny. You label rookie of the year recipient and pro bowlers busts?

Using that logic, every single player Saban has put into the NFL has been a bust.

I cant think of a single former Saban player who has won an individual award (ROY) or made it to a pro bowl. Not a single one. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Can't think of a former Bama QB to actually win a game in the NFL. You have to go back 3 or 4 decades to find one.

If I told you to name the best defensive player Saban has put in the league, whatever name you come up with, that player is average at best.

first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter