re: What if???

That defense for Auburn that year only gave up like 13 points a game. They completely shut down David Greene who is much better than McElroy, smacked a ranked UT twice, and held the defending champs to single digit points. There is no way that a Bama offense, that could not even get 300 yards of offense against the 2009 Auburn defense, would be able to do anything against the 2004 Auburn defense.