re: Biggest melt playoff scenarios?

quote:

---

I'm not certain Alabama gets a shot, but I am absolutely certain that Alabama deserves a shot over an OSU team that has a 31 point defeat to average on its resume.

---

This is purely my opinion and not in the rules. I think a 4 team play-off should only ever consist of the 4 conference champs with the best resumes. Not winning your division should 100% rule you out. And yes I'd feel that way if LSU was in bama's position right now.