re: Bama and 5* Recruits

quote:

---

But the statement is if you are a five star and sign with bama you will get drafted in the first round. unless you are not top 15 5 star, unless you get kicked out of the program, unless you got arrested, unless you quit on the team, unless... unless..., unless...

Do you not see the fail in that? What happens to them once they sign is a direct result from being there. How do oyu know if they had not taken another road that same circumstance would have happened? you dont, which is why you cant exclude them

---

As far as I can tell, the "fail" was in the OP's understanding of the stat (a UGA fan, so I'm not going to ascribe nefarious motives to him here.) My discussion was almost entirely intellectual, focusing on what a legitimate stat would look like and the various parameters involved in developing said stat. I get the feeling that your objection is less on intellectual terms than in terms of whether a reasonable/logical presentation of a statistic reflects well on your rival.