re: I'm Mad ---- Vol. 2 --- BCSNC Game features the #1 SOS team v. the #38 SOS team.

quote:

---

No we don't. If you finish the season after championship weekend 8th, why should you deserve a spot? 4 is perfect.

---

Because (just using this year as an example), Alabama would beat the frick out of all the following teams and it's not fair that Auburn had to face Alabama and win to get to the NC game, but these guys didn't even come remotely close:

1. Florida State
4. Michigan State
5. Stanford
6. Baylor

Using your method, those teams get an equal shot without going through Alabama. You really think Michigan State belongs in the playoffs this year?

Top 4 teams in would result in this seeding and likely results:

1 Florida State -- 5 Stanford
2 Auburn -- 4 Michigan State

One-loss Michigan State and two-loss Stanford get a shot over Alabama, is what you are saying.


Now Top 8:

1 Florida State – 8 Missouri

2 Auburn – 7 Ohio State

3 Alabama – 6 Baylor

4 Michigan State – 5 Stanford