re: DSOR: Herschel or Bo?

quote:

---

Can I have Bo but make him not have the hips of an 80 year old woman or have to sit out a couple of seasons with Super AIDS?

Old Paper Tush was great at running up walls and stuff. Not made to last though.

---

If you want a guy on your team who is a consistent player, who will keep defenses honest, you go with Hershel.

If you want a play-maker who has the ability to make things happen and gives defenses fits, you go with Bo.

You can get consistency at RB with what the NFL has gone to -- RB by committee. You CAN'T get by committee, the play-maker who always gives you a chance to score on any play.

These are really two totally different players. It's like asking if the best OL in the history of the game is better than the best kicker. They both do the job very well, and their absence will hurt, but they can be replaced.