Wow, so you need me to explain it to you even though several people already have done so in the thread? You're being willfully ignorant of the facts and using the results of the game as justification. No one in this thread is arguing that Bama won. However, that has no bearing on whether or not they deserved to be there. You're using the outcome of a decision to justify that decision, which is intellectually dishonest. Especially in this case, since everyone is debating the rationale of the decision, not its outcome. Regardless of outcome, the rationale of the decision was flawed due to Bama's media darling status and Saban's campaigning.

quote:
Why the hate for LSU???????????

Honestly? The fans.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by Slinger16

Not Louisiana

Member since Jun 2007

21872 posts

Posted on 9/16/12 at 8:04 am to SoonerBorn

quote:
Wow, so you need me to explain it to you even though several people already have done so in the thread? You're being willfully ignorant of the facts and using the results of the game as justification. No one in this thread is arguing that Bama won. However, that has no bearing on whether or not they deserved to be there. You're using the outcome of a decision to justify that decision, which is intellectually dishonest. Especially in this case, since everyone is debating the rationale of the decision, not its outcome. Regardless of outcome, the rationale of the decision was flawed due to Bama's media darling status and Saban's campaigning.

exactly, the gumps whored their way into a title shot. A title shot that they did not deserve by any reasonable measure.

0 ...

Report Post

More Sports - Replies to Post

Return To Board

Page 1

Return To Board