Jake Locker or Cam Newton?

Jefferson goes before both

quote:

---

Who will be drafted higher in next year's NFL Draft?

---

tough question right now I'd go with Newton.

By April that could change.

Personally, I'd take Locker without hesitation.

quote:

---

and why is that?

---

Does this really need to be explained? So many guys were oozing over him as the #1 guy on their boards coming into this season. He did nothing to live up to that. He is just way too inaccurate to be an NFL QB.

Not only is Newton a much better runner but he's a WAY better passer.

I'd take Newton. Money going to his head won't be an issue

quote:

---

Hell yes it does.

---

No, it really shouldnt. Newton is by far the better QB.

quote:

---

and? He plays for Wash. with next to no talent and he was hurt most of the year.

---

Wrong. Chris Polk is as legit as a RB you'll find and he has Kearse at WR, an NFL talent next year. It's not like Newton stepped into a powerhouse at Auburn, they lost 5 games last year.

There is no excuse for how poorly Locker played this year and is why no one is talking about him anymore. He should of declared last year when some team would of been dumb enough to take him in the Top 10/15. Good chance he'll fall out the 1st round now. Locker is a nothing at QB without his running ability and he cant run around all the time in the NFL. He isn't starting material by any means in the NFL. Newton is, he can throw the ball very well.

You know what QBs had a higher QB rating than Locker this year? Remember that terrible MSU QB a few years ago who threw like 5 or 6 picks against LSU? Wesley Carroll? He had a higher QB rating than him this year at FIU. Matt Simms, the former starter at Tennessee who was beat out by a true freshman later in the year...higher QB rating this year than Jake Locker.

There is zero excuse for the poor display Locker put on this year, his last year, his 4th year starting (did miss a lot his sophomore year).

quote:

---

you seen alot of him? I disagree.

---

Yes I have, he's terribly inaccurate. 54% career completion % is pretty terrible for a supposed "top QB".

quote:

---

in you opinion.

---

Cam Newton - #1 QB Rating in NCAA
Jake Locker - #69 QB Rating in NCAA

On top of that it's clear to any level headed person watching the two Newton is miles ahead of Locker throwing the football in any aspect. Power, accuracy, etc...

newton duh... ill just be happy to see auburn next year without him

quote:

---

Newton is by far the better QB.

---

based on what? Why is he better?

quote:

---

Chris Polk is as legit as a RB you'll find

---

agreed I was talking more about o.line/ WR's.

quote:

---

he has Kearse at WR, an NFL talent next year

---

true but when Kearse was being covered by a good CB he went cold. (see Nebraska game)

quote:

---

It's not like Newton stepped into a powerhouse at Auburn, they lost 5 games last year.

---

I'd take Dyer and Adams over Polk and kearse all day every day.

Also Auburn's Offense as a whole is better.

quote:

---

There is no excuse for how poorly Locker played this year

---

Injuries aren't good reasons?

quote:

---

no one is talking about him anymore.

---

plenty of people are just not as the top qb.

quote:

---

Good chance he'll fall out the 1st round now.

---

couldn't disagree more. I still think he will go in the 1st as does every mock draft.

quote:

---

Locker is a nothing at QB without his running ability

---

either you haven't watched him or you have a serious grudge against him.

quote:

---

He isn't starting material by any means in the NFL.

---

same thing people said about Tebow and Mccoy.

quote:

---

You know what QBs had a higher QB rating than Locker this year?

---

He played hurt this year and he really shouldn't have.

quote:

---

54% career completion % is pretty terrible for a supposed "top QB".

---

doesn't take dropped passes into account and other factors. I'm not a Big stats guy but I agree the stats are concerning.

quote:

---

it's clear to any level headed person watching the two Newton is miles ahead of Locker throwing the football in any aspect. Power, accuracy, etc.

---

Geez you really hate Locker. Agree to disagree.

quote:

---

Jake Locker = Ryan Leaf
Cam Newton = JaMarcus Russell

---

some bold predictions there.

quote:

---

Nick Foles

---

great qb and probably will be the #1 guy next year. I still think Locker is better but time will tell.

quote:

---

1 SEC quarterback better than Cam Newton (Mallett).

---

that's pretty controversial.

quote:

---

any half wit can tell Newton is by far better by watching the two play.

---

in a pro style offense which do you think would be better?

quote:

---

And Darvin Adams didn't?

---

agreed he did in every game but Clemson. However, Auburn is a better team and if Darvin wasn't playing well Cam could win the game by himself or use his TE, or #2 WR or even his #3 WR.

quote:

---

Kearse and Polk are easily as good as Adams and Dyer. All numbers together they look very similar as well.

---

Auburn plays better competition. No telling what those players would do vs. weaker competition.

quote:

---

clear out of everyone's Top 10/15?

---

whose?

quote:

---

Where? I havent heard about him since the beginning of the season.

---

every draft website.

stats don't always tell the whole story and I don't think they do in Locker's case. He has had a bad year this year there is no denying that and Wash. in general had a terrible year.

He still has a strong chance to be a 1st rd. pick and some mocks i've seen have him as a top 15 pick.

I don't think we can have a full idea of what Locker is capable of until the Sr. Bowl when he has elite talent around him.

Adam, someone who-s never seen him play, or hasn-t the proper criteria to analyze him, is seriously bateing you. Cut lines.

Merry Christmas.